Casual Italian eatery offering patio seating & a menu of classic pastas, seafood & pizza creations. Based on 555 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
141 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 219-9068
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: orderilpiccolobufalo.com
Reviews
steven latchaw
We sat outside and the staff was working hard to make sure that experience was good. The food was nice and flavorful. The calzone was large and filled. The gnocchi was fine. Looking at our food and that of those around us I think the oven items looked the best. It’s not fast pizza but was good.
… more
Heather Brown
We met Sam outside and he was so personable. He told us about their wonderful homemade pasta. We are SO happy we stopped here because their pasta was delicious and light. The dessert we got was also WONDERFUL. Oh and the bread at the beginning of the meal is made from their pizza dough. Warm and soooo good!! If you’re a bread person you must come try. But also many dishes for everyone’s taste!
… more
Ehsap YILDIRIM
It was the worst restaurant I’ve ever experienced in my life. They had a crazy woman manager who kept shouting. I ordered chicken parmigana, the chicken was half cold and half hot, the pasta sauce was very bad and the chicken was not cooked. I wanted to eat half of it because I was so hungry but I couldn’t eat any more and then when I told her that the food was so bad the woman shouted at me that you have already finished half of it and you have to pay for half of it. I was shocked, I didn’t say I wasn’t going to pay but her behavior was very rude. Then the waiter came to me and said that he was very sorry for this situation and stated again that I had to pay half the price, I said that there was no problem with the payment, I said that the food was very bad, the manager saw that we were talking to the waiter from a distance and started shouting that I am the manager of this place and only I make decisions. The manager of a restaurant should not do this to her customer. I regret that I even paid the money, I wish I had called the police. I do not recommend it to anyone, I definitely do not recommend you to go. If you want to have a nice meal in a peaceful environment, you should definitely not choose here!!!!!
… more
Matt Sullivan
We enjoyed the open-air dining in this great little restaurant. The pizza was really good, the drinks were cold, and the server was very nice. Like anything that’s worth waiting for, the pizza took awhile to come out – but well-worth the wait. We were in Little Italy to get some delicious Italian food, and to see some of the sites where the Mafia had/has been active; we got both!
… more
Austin Mills
While walking down little Italy we were bombarded with hosts and hostesses trying to get us in their door. That is, until we came across this restaurant. Instead of trying to drag us in the door, the host welcomed us with open arms. He described his favorite dishes with gusto but a relaxed demeanor. Even calling to his regulars as they walked by, proving they cared more about satisfied customers instead of just another sale.
… more
BuLLeTs
Oh my god me and my girl went here last night. Had the beef ravioli and pizza Bella, it was amazing. I was sweating while eating from the sheer joy of the flavor from the sauce. Amazing experience, can’t wait to come back with my parents
… more
Kim and Joe Cooper
Nice location. Food was good. Clean. Cheerful. What I didn’t like was that 2 of our 3 pizzas came. We waited 20 min for the third. That was miserable as we had to watch others in our party eat. No discount or free pizza for their mess up. Many many other pizzas came out before our 3rd. So clearly the order was not placed. I asked for refills and did not get them. I understand places are short staffed but this was unacceptable. Papa manager clearly could have helped his staff a bit more in my opinion. Also, we had 6 in our party so we were charged a mandatory tip amount. Not happy with that either. We will not be back.
… more
Thomas Cardona
It was a very nice restaurant, we were greeted by a host at the outside and convinced us to try their delicious pizza. We when in and had a wonderful lunch, it was delicious, and the music was fantastic, it is the perfect spot to have lunch at Little Italy, and it is also cheap too compare to other restaurants!
… more
Woodss Gaming
The owner himself offered to cover our meal if we didn’t think it was fantastic. Needless to say, we ended up grabbing the check. This place was great. I had the Margherita pizza and my girlfriend got the shrimp carbonara. Both dishes were absolutely great. We also started off with the bruschetta which we VERY highly recommend!
… more
Paul Sivo
What an incredible experience this restaurant was. The food was authentic Italian food and was absolutely delicious. The care the staff took of both my wife and I was incredible. The drinks were made to perfection and the my wife finally got here authentic canoli and cappuccino. If your ever in Little Italy on Mulberry Street, I would definitely recommend this establishment.
… more
… View more