Iron Skillet Menu – New Paris, OH

Type : Restaurant

Location : New Paris, OH

Iron Skillet has been serving homecooked meals to highway travelers for more than 40 years. With fresh food served by friendly folks, we’re committed to providing a high-quality dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a hearty breakfast with biscuits, sausage gravy and eggs like our Southern Tradition or you’d prefer a juicy burger like our Double Bacon & Cheese Steak Burger, we have a meal you’ll love. You won’t want to miss out on our line-up of mouthwatering steaks and dinner classics like Chicken Fried Steak. Craving something sweet? We’ve got that too! Breakfast, lunch or dinner, come see us at Iron Skillet in Petro New Paris for your next meal.

Based on 390 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Iron Skillet 45347

Address:
9787 US-40, New Paris, OH 45347

Phone: (937) 437-8593

Website:

Hours

Sunday 7 AM–11 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
7 AM–11 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 7 AM–11 PM
Wednesday 7 AM–11 PM
Thursday 7 AM–11 PM
Friday 7 AM–11 PM
Saturday 7 AM–11 PM

Menu

Soups And Salads
Homemade Chili With Beans
topped with shredded cheese and onions
$4.59
Soup Bar
prepared fresh daily
$3.99
Garden Chicken Salad
our signature salad topped with choice of grilled or fried chicken, grape tomatoes and shredded cheddar cheese. served with garlic toast and choice of dressing
$7.89
Beefy Burgers
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
two juicy beef patties with bacon & four slices of cheese. served with your choice of fries, coleslaw, pinto beans or soup
$8.99
Patty Melt On Whole Grain Bread
a thick juicy patty topped with melted swiss cheese and grilled onions
$7.69
Chili Burger
a thick juicy burger smothered in homemade chili with beans and onion slices
$7.69
Skillet Hamburger
served with all the fixins
$7.19
Skillet Cheeseburger
served with your choice of american or swiss cheese on a golden bun
$7.39
Skillet Bacon Cheeseburger
served with your choice of american or swiss cheese and smoked bacon
$7.69
Skillet Baskets
Kickin Chicken Basket
tender chicken strips deep-fried to a golden crisp and tossed with kickin boom boom sauce. served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing
$6.99
Chicken Strips
deep-fried and served with barbecue sauce or ranch dressing
$6.99
Golden Shrimp
shrimp deep-fried golden brown, served with cocktail sauce
$6.99
Fish & Fries
lightly breaded and deep-fried to a golden brown, served with tartar sauce
$6.99
Fresh Made Sandwiches
Grilled Italian Sausage Hoagie
a zesty italian sausage grilled and topped with grilled onions, bell peppers and mozzarella cheese. served on a hoagie bun
Philly Steak Sandwich
sliced beef piled high on a bun with grilled onions, mushrooms and bell peppers, topped with swiss cheese
$8.19
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
crisp bacon, fresh lettuce and tomato slices make this sandwich something special
$6.49
Club Sandwich
ham, smoked turkey breast, strips of bacon, lettuce, tomato, swiss and american cheeses and mayo on three slices of texas toast
$8.59
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
boneless chicken breast, grilled crisp, served on a european style roll, smothered in spaghetti sauce and topped with melted mozzarella and parmesan cheeses
$7.99
Chicken Breast Sandwich
we serve this sandwich on whole grain bread with lettuce and tomato
$7.39
Open-Faced Pot Roast Sandwich
slow cooked pot roast topped with rich brown gravy. served over texas toast with pickle chips on the side
$7.89
Sirloin Steak Sandwich
perfectly seasoned sirloin steak cooked to your order then smothered with grilled onions and served open-faced on thick texas toast
$8.49
Chicken Quesadilla
two flour tortillas filled with seasoned chicken breast strips, cheddar cheese, grilled onions and bell peppers. served with pinto beans, sour cream and salsa
$7.99
Sizzlin’ Steaks
One Pound Top Sirloin
one pound hand-cut top sirloin steak seasoned and cooked to order served with one side and a trip to our soup and salad bar
$12.99
Steerburger
broiled chopped beef steak smothered with grilled onions and rich brown gravy
$9.99
Texas Steerburger
16-oz. broiled chopped beef steak cooked to order* with your choice of toppings: grilled onions & brown gravy, swiss cheese, mushrooms & onions includes one side and a trip to our soup and salad bar
$11.59
Sirloin Steak
flavorful sirloin steak seasoned and cooked to your taste
$10.39
Sirloin Steak With Fried Shrimp Or Shrimp Scampi
a juicy sirloin steak cooked to order* and served with crispy fried shrimp or topped with sauteed shrimp and mushrooms in scampi sauce
$12.49
Homestyle Favorites
Sirloin Steak Tips
tender tips of steak are sauteed with bell peppers and onions. finished with a rich brown sauce and served over long grain & wild rice
$9.99
Beef Liver & Onions
two pieces of liver grilled with onions and covered in brown gravy. served with mashed potatoes and gravy
$8.49
Pot Roast
slow roasted pot roast with onions and brown gravy. served with mashed potatoes and gravy
$9.99
Side Items
Baked Potato
French Fries
Hash Browns
Mashed Potatoes
Pinto Beans
Coleslaw
Mixed Vegetables
Sliced Tomato
Cottage Cheese
Pasta Creations
Chicken Or Shrimp Ziti Alfredo
rich alfredo sauce tossed with tender ziti pasta and topped with your choice of either grilled chicken breast or sauteed shrimp. finished with fresh shredded parmesan cheese & green onions. with chicken, with shrimp
Grilled Italian Sausage & Pasta Dinner
spicy sliced italian sausage grilled with bell peppers and sweet onions. served with spaghetti noodles, topped with our meat sauce and mozzarella cheese. served with garlic toast
Moms Pot Roast & Pasta Dinner
slow roasted pot roast with onions & a special blend of sauces served over a bed of noodles
Spaghetti
spaghetti covered in classic italian meat sauce. served with garlic bread
$7.99
Chicken Parmesan
boneless chicken breast, grilled crisp and golden, then smothered in spaghetti sauce and topped with melted mozzarella and parmesan cheeses. served with garlic bread
$9.99
Seafood
Wild Alaskan Salmon
alaskan salmon seasoned and grilled to perfection
$10.19
Grilled Flounder
alaskan flounder seasoned and grilled to perfection
$9.89
Fried Shrimp
half a pound of golden fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce
$9.99
Captains Seafood Platter
dont worry about choosing just one… you can enjoy golden fried shrimp, breaded clam strips and breaded fish fillets
$13.59
Chicken
Chicken-Fried Chicken
fried just like our chicken-fried steak, but its a chicken breast with creamy gravy on top
$9.39
Chicken Strips
served with your choice of gravy, ranch dressing or barbecue sauce
$9.29
Sweet Treats
French Silk Chocolate Pie
chocolate pie a light airy mousse topped with whipped cream and chocolate curls
$3.69
Strawberry Shortcake
shortcake an american favorite! moist pound cake topped with strawberries in sauce
$2.49
A La Mode!
add a scoop of ice cream for only
$0.99
No Sugar Added Apple Pie
naturally sweet apples with cinnamon & spices. no sugar added
$2.59
Hot Fudge Or Strawberry Sundae
three scoops of ice cream smothered in hot fudge or sliced strawberries with syrup and lots of whipped cream
$2.79
Root Beer Float
two scoops of vanilla ice cream in a large glass of ice cold root beer
$3.99
Ice Cream
choose your favorite vanilla, strawberry or chocolate ice cream
$1.49

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Thomas wright
Ok, in a nutshell, service was lousy, food was good. Server brought me half full coffee pot both times, and I made the mistake of looking inside of it, oh nooo they do not clean these thing very often.

… more

Tracey Tuttle
The service was good Kelly, Angel, and Kat were extremely polite and good natured. The food left a lot to be desired tho, when someone ask for over easy eggs they don’t want hard ones. The gravy was okay, but the biscuits were nasty. How hard is it to bake a biscuit? Grilling them on top the grill and making them hard is nasty. Coffee was good, they do need to add different creamers for people, not everyone likes half and half. Neither me nor my husband ate everything, it just leaves a bad taste in your mouth. I don’t know who made the menu or the prices, but I can go to Casey’s and get cheaper biscuits and gravy. 13.99 for 2 grilled biscuits and gravy with 2 over easy eggs, I’m sorry thats price gouging at it’s worst. Than spend 4 on a cup of coffee when you can go to the Petro store itself and get a large coffee for under 3, now that’s ridiculous. I’m sorry but I will never be coming back here.

… more

Domagoj Kerestes
Iron Skillet need bring back self soup and salad bar like before pandemic ! ! , Like this they have way-way less customers in all their franchise restaurants… also no more beef liver&onions but their website say they have it…..

… more

Edward Antrobus Jr
I’ve ordering the pork chop breakfast at Petros all over for several months. Over the last couple of months, the chop has been getting fattier. More fat than I’ve ever encountered before. I ate here yesterday. The chop had a thick band of gristle near the outside edge. I’ve never experienced that in my life. This is pure lazy on the part of the person preparing the chop before breading. I get a pork chop breakfast at a couple of independent truck shops. None of them do a breaded & deep fried chop. But their chops are light years higher quality.

… more

Laura Vareikyte
This Country and Company is becoming a deep hole. 20+ years been stopping for a meal, use to be 3 eggs in a traditional al breakfast meal, now they change it to a 2, extra eggs becomes $1.30 out of your pocket… Seriously? $18 for a traditional breakfast meal with no coffee or drink from the iron plate??? No, thank you

… more

Kevin Campbell
Been stopping here for almost 30yrs my favorite place. No more they are price gouging 3 to 5 dollars over what ALL OTHER IRON SKILLETS charge on every meal

… more

Susanne Bentley
Another great experience at this Iron Skillet. Sam, our waitress was just awesome. We as OTR truck drivers see a lot of very bad places lately, but this place is outstanding. Thank you Sam

… more

Jim Cox
Seat yourself at this location. The waitress was very friendly and helpful. Order orders were served quickly a d correctly. Plenty of parking and easy to find.

… more

Bradc
The food was really good, hot, fresh and fast. Natalie, was a great warm professional genuine person, and she got me refills before I ran out. Kelly, the manager, was great to deal with. Highly recommend!

… more

Corey Reynolds
If you order breakfast make sure to order double hashbrowns. The portions they give you is a joke. 2 bites and that’s all. Only iron skillet I’ve been to that serves a joke of a portion

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions