Based on 53 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2102 Central Ave, Seaside Park, NJ 08752
Phone: (732) 250-4376
Website: https://www.facebook.com/people/Island-Beach-Fish-Company/100090016064759/
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daniel Castellanos
Came here for drinks in March and met the owners who were super nice. They were actually comping us for bad service at their other establishment.
… more
Big Shirley
So we got the pizza which was burnt, really salty and like another review claimed, lacked one of the advertised ingredient. No specials were mentioned until I heard them being offered at a different table by a different server(after we ordered). We also were told that 3 of the items on the menu that we were trying to order were no longer on the menu but they didn’t simply just reprint menus(the waiter said the unavailable food was getting too many complaints so they took it off the menu). They crossed them out with a marker which was washed off on one menu and no signs of them being crossed out were seen on my menu. A fairly small tropical drink that was suggested was $15 and was mostly random juices and a bit too sweet. Overall the menu is kind of limited, there’s definitely no Chef there to help execute what is available and I’m not sure they can last like that with a single line cook. It is dog friendly but that’s the only draw. No drink menu and the server didn’t seem to know much about what they had. I probably wouldn’t return. There just wasn’t anything memorable.
… more
Eddye R
We were so excited. They are pet friendly. So we were able to bring our small dogs with us. They even brought out bowls of ice water for the dogs. I got a lobster BLT. It was huge and so good. We also got drunken clams I think it was which she said was delicious.
… more
Michael William Majorczak
Great Seafood and Service. Sat inside at the bar. Friendly Bar Tender named Charlie.
… more
K V
Limited menu. Despite selling fresh seafood, virtually NO fresh seafood on the menu. Random use of goat cheese in too many dishes. Good luck finding the lobster on the “Lobster” pizza (w/ goat cheese). Tried to order the stuffed mushrooms but the waiter told us not to because most people were disappointed which was our overall feeling about the entire meal. We had several items and would not recommend anything. I assume it’s only busy because the options are so limited in So. Sspk that people have no choice. On the positive side, it’s a nice casual atmosphere with a fun beach vibe. Might be a good a place to grab a drink.
… more
Pat B
Place looks very inviting. Rating was based on two main things. First, half the food was good and the other was poor to less than average. Second, we waited an hour for one of the things ordered. It wasn’t busy and we had to ask over and over for a status. Very disappointing, not going back.
… more
Cris F
Had the bar pizzas on Aug 23rd and they were fantastic. The pizza was cooked to perfection!!! Best pizza I’ve had in a while. The wings were also a hit with our table. Service was friendly and attentive.
… more
Mark Miller
It seemed like a cool place from the outside but after 30 minutes of waiting for a waitress, I decided to ask. I was told someone would be over. We gave our order and 45 minutes later and no one asking to refresh our drinks, we walked out. I looked for manager but no one there was older than maybe 21 or 22. For a new place that just opened, I would think someone who owned it would be there overseeing things. No one seems to care if we were there or not. If you are OK with begging for service then give it a try.
… more
Laura Baron
Cute outdoor patio area, although they could use more shady areas. The service however was terrible. We ordered pizza and 3 entrees. They were out of cod (on a Tues during dinner hour). Pizza came out and then 35+ minutes later one of the entrees. Then we found out they were also out of shrimp….. we decided to just close the bill and go somewhere else for dinner because by that time we were starving and annoyed waiting an hour plus for a pizza and 1 entree. Considering our meal was such a disaster, it would’ve been nice to have a manager come over and at least hear our concerns. Will possibly try it again next season to see if they get their act together.
… more
MindySue Fry
Great options! Fun atmosphere. Great location! The customer service is amazing.
… more
… View more