Longtime seafood market for local catches, plus prepared food like sandwiches, soups & platters. Based on 281 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
655 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738
Phone: (631) 698-7700
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mark Kline
We went here to buy fresh fish. Most of the fish were in refrigerator glass cases and looked old and not fresh. I did buy a piece of salmon and it was not bad but not the freshest. We did buy a bowl of spicy crab soup that was really good. Prices were high and quality was low. Would not go back there at all. Looks like they specialize in cooked seafood. They had many selections of fried or baked seafood in refrigerated cases.
… more
Todd Minchew
Incredible food! Extremely friendly staff. Offered us food samples before we even ordered. Shrimp and dill was the best shrimp I’ve ever had. The lobster bisque was absolutely amazing. The scallops were cooked to perfection. This little spot is the best hidden gem in this area. Oh…and the seafood market? Best prices. They do it right. They know what they’re doing. They explain everything to you and how it’s priced and believe me, it’s priced to your benefit. Not theirs.
… more
Jaclyn Rauchfuss
Cute little fish market and counter with a couple tables for a quick bite to eat or take out orders. The food was plentiful and delicious, and the staff was wonderful. We definitely plan to go back!
… more
Erica Brown
The Owners and staff we excellent and friendly. We arrived just before closing, everyone was nice and patient. This was our first visit, they helped us with everything and gave us samples to try new things. The food was great! The owner has an awesome shark display from Nemo, he shared the great stories about the fish on display, it was fun and entertaining while we waited for our food to be prepared. Our family will definitely return again.
… more
Peg McCoy
I chose this place because of all of the great reviews. I am a very picky eater and I love their food. Freshly made to order- we had Flounder fillet dinners. 2 huge pieces of flounder and lots of fries – 2 dinners under $20. Staff was extremely nice! I highly recommend this place
… more
A pocket Full of sunshine
Yesterday When I walked into Island fish I was greeted by a wonderful person with a great vibe! Failed to remember their name tho. My apologies! Soo friendly! Than a very nice man who may be the owner or chef, offered me a shrimp with dill sauce to try. I do not like mayo, tried it anyway. It was amazing! Great sauce! Then I get served a sample of their mango slushy, it was also amazing and fresh tasting! This is all while my order is being rung up. So, I buy the slushy. The man says that would be great with alcohol! I said you’re right! Than he comes out and puts some vodka in my slushy! Lol!! Talk about the royal treatment!! Such a friendly vibe and that’s worth a million bucks! By the way my salmon, and potato’s were AMAZING!! Ohh my sweet potato fries, off the hook too! The portion sizes, on POINT! Better than any restaurant! You never get a decent portion in a restaurant. Great job to the owners, chef and staff! Made my day with some fantastic food and friendly service.
… more
Megan Mil
Super sweet gem! I love this spot everything is so fresh and full of flavor!! Delicious seafood and the soup is so yummy!! People are the sweetest. Will be back.
… more
elizabeth avalos
Went to this fish market to purchase lobsters and scallops. The wait staff was excellent.! He made AWESOME suggestions! Thanks for even letting me sample fresh made dry sea scallops!! They were amazing! See you guys soon for more delicious seafood! Here is a pic of my end RESULT!
… more
Mike Wallace
This is a little hidden gem, that is always serving fantastic products and customer service…. The staff is very personable and the food is excellent… I highly recommend Island Fish
… more
Perla Laureano
In awe; great food & great service. Everyone so friendly, we met the owner and he was so kind to us. Amazing place!
… more
… View more