Based on 120 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5549 Mountville Rd, Adamstown, MD 21710
Phone: (301) 874-3600
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Camilo Toro
Don’t want to be overly critical on this review because their Walkersville location is pretty good and I have had solid experiences there before which led me to try out the Adamstown location. I was very surprised with the price I got two large pizzas with 5 toppings each and 2 chicken Caesar salads for my family and I was never told the final price over the phone. I get to the store and it was $88.50. I usually get the same order at Pizza Blitz in Frederick and it is at least 20-30$ cheaper and so much better. The pizza here is awful for the price, any digiorno or Pizza Hut pizza is better. The pizza really didn’t look half bad from first glance, things changed after the first bite. The crust was burnt and it tasted and had the consistency of cardboard. The sauce was very bland. The toppings were okay but I got broccoli on my pizza which I threw away after two slices and the broccoli tasted like it was microwaved in a plastic bag and it was still wet and half frozen. As for the Chicken Caesar salad it might have been worse than the pizza. Wilted lettuce everywhere, croutons were old and the chicken had zero flavor and was over cooked, tough to bite into, and not fresh. Barely any Caesar dressing given on the side either. This is my first time writing a review on an eatery in my life but my experience at Italia in Adamstown was that bad that I felt the need to write this review. Something has to be done with the high prices and the overall product asap.
… more
Kate Wackerle
A huge shout out to our lovely delivery driver – a part of our order wasn’t delivered. They said they could add it to our next order, but that a mistake was made and they didn’t have the item. No big, we order enough and that would be fine. But, they went above and beyond to correct the mistake and came back with the missing part of our order a little while later. Above and beyond (and made a 4 year old very happy). THANK YOU!
… more
Allen Nuccio
Legitimately the best pizza in the Frederick area, and I have tried just about all of them. You wouldn’t think given the location and the fact that this particular location has housed numerous other failed Italian restaurants, but this place is actually great. The crust is perfect, the sauce is sweet and tangy (applied in the perfect amount) and the cheese is delicious. All the toppings are great, everything seems fresh. It all comes together incredibly well with just the appropriate amount of oiliness to finish it off. Their other offerings are also good, but their pies are fantastic.
… more
Jennifer Diaz
Best New York-style pizza in G
… more
N Sol
Great little Italian restaurant. Had wings, gyro pizza and salad. For dessert the tiramisu. Everything was wonderful from the sweet blond who took our order to the quality of the food!
… more
Jay Doherty
Excellent pizza from someone who spent the first 43 years of his life in New York!
… more
Alex Marsh-Brandes
I was in the phone with one guy and I could barely hear the guy. I had to ask him to repeat himself several times and he ended up raising his voice at me what a horrible guy
… more
Jeanne Fourie Zirkelbach
Loved this little place. The Sicilian pizza and lasagna were awesome, the salad was delicious with loads of fresh ingredients! Will go out of my way for another visit anytime. Service was fast and very friendly as we dined in.
… more
Heather Curtis
Absolutely delicious! I’m a native New Yorker and am very fussy about my pizza, and I love the Sicilian here! I stumbled across Italia NY Pizza 2 while looking for reviews of a pizza place close to Rocky Point Creamery. The reviews were good, and I saw something I have only seen once outside of NY: Sicilian. I had no idea what to expect but needed to try it. I was blown away. A week later, I drove half an hour from
… more
Klara Ramnath
We started coming here while checking out the Adamstown area for our new house. It immediately became our favorite pizza place in all of the Frederick area. Fresh, clean ingredients, and the service has always been wonderful. We order take out here on a weekly basis!
… more
… View more