Strip-mall outpost providing New York-style pies & slices, plus cheesesteaks, calzones & other eats. Based on 386 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3405 Hillsborough Rd A4, Durham, NC 27705
Phone: (984) 219-6101
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9:45 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9:45 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9:45 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9:45 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9:45 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ana karina Jordan
I forgot to take pictures of the cheese steak sub, I highly recommend the sub. I ordered a Hawaiian pizza, it was ok but not die for it. I never been disappointed with the sandwich and there are different types. It worth the money you pay. The service is really fast and they always try to be cordial with customers.
… more
Nickie
Ordered the Neapolitan Style pizza through Uber Eats, it was real good. Hot and fresh.
… more
Monica Abdelmalak
I don’t think the pizza here is made to order. The pizzas we got today definitely looked like they were prebaked cheese pizzas that were just reheated with the toppings we picked and some extra cheese sprinkled on. The end product is just way too much cheese on top that slides off the pizza rather than being correctly baked into the sauce. You can even tell the pizzas were sliced underneath the layer of cheese like it was meant to be a pie for pizza by the slice that they then just served whole to me instead. I’m not really sure what the good reviews are about. For the price and how little time it takes to bake a pizza, there’s no reason for this.
… more
Taina Cook
I ordered a pizza and cheesecake. The huge slices of cheesecake were in a glass display and already prepackaged in clear, plastic containers
… more
Elizabeth Buchanan
I grew up eating at the Italian Pizzeria on Guess. I’ve never had such a bad experience with IP. Ordered a pizza with spinach, ricotta, sausage and black olives. The spinach was defrosted frozen spinach, not fresh and they didn’t even drain it so it made the whole pizza soggy. Then they just smeared the ricotta cheese on top. Wings were soggy, not crispy and they just dumped some bbq sauce on top instead of tossing them. Just gross.
… more
Nicole Kingsmore
First off they need to teach the employee who sneezed about six times how to properly wash his hands before dealing with customers. Running his hands under water for three seconds with out any soap is unacceptable! This place used to be really good but as of my experience today, I will never go back for the price of one cheese steak sandwich (11.50) with no toppings, side or drink.The quality and taste of sandwich was a very, very big disappointment. There was so little cheese I couldn’t even taste any. And so much unflavored steak it was not worth it at all. Very dry and tasteless. I alway try to support local but this was just a big disappointment overall…I’ll be going to Jersey Mike’s or international on 9th street next time for a cheesesteak, they do a way better one.
… more
Heather P. McPherson
One of our favorite pizza places when I was a kid and still to this day. Plain cheese pizza is divine and their Philly cheese steaks, no where else does then better. Large menu for f pizzas, cold and hot subs, other Italian favorites like lasagna or eggplant parm and classic Italian desserts like tiramisu. Our go to “Nobody wants to cook spot” Tickled when Hillsborough store opened, mins from our house. Clean, friendly staff, fast service and uni sex restrooms. Delivery, daily specials and kid friendly! Free parking and wheel chair accessible
… more
Robert Addison
Great Italian food. Fast but slow enough to make the food good. I eat here at least 3 times a month or sometimes 1 or 2 more time’s. Just got a Philly cheese steak Thursday night and it was delicious. Thanks to all the people who work there.. keep serving your food good and I’ll be coming back again and again. R.Addison..jr.
… more
Retha Tuck
The best cheese steak hoagie in town. Very fast and accurate service.
… more
Douglas Pender
Great food but I don’t enjoy being panhandle as soon as I walk in from some shady looking dude asking me to help pay for his food. I just walked out and went somewhere else. Take care of your panhandling problem.
… more
… View more