Pizzas & Italian favorites dished up in a warm, low-key mini-chain eatery with ample booth seating. Based on 342 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3968 Hempstead Tpke, Bethpage, NY 11714
Phone: (516) 520-6460
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
michael lapadula
I want a thick crust double cheese & pepperoni oh but no anchovies I mean no anchovies! You put anchovies on this thing & your in big trouble okay!! Italiano Pie Bar in Bethpage is pizzalious! Thankfully I had lucy as my server & she made sure I had no anchovies on my Pizza! Thank you Lucy you were super nice & accommodating pure definition of service with a smile Im asking for you next time! FyI the baked clams in the citrus butter sauce was awsomenova! Makes me wanna say COWABUNGA!
… more
CJ
The last few times I ordered pizza well done it came as a gooey, soggy mess. And waaay too much cheese. Read the special instructions on orders. Whether directly through you or another app. And teach your cooks how to properly make a well done pizza.
… more
Manuel M
You should give it a try. It’s very good restaurant and the staff are very nice. I would recommend to come to this restaurant.
… more
Denise Henderson
Went there for Brunch. OMG the breakfast pizza, and Eggs Benny was outrageous.The food was so good. I can’t wait till next weekend . They put in a bar in and redid the booths. Italiano is beautiful and DELICIOUS! Jorge is an amazing server. William is a terrific manager who runs food, or anything else to help his crew.
… more
LP HARRIS
YES! Working late & called 10min. before they close on a Sunday & still the nice guy agreed to deliver pizza on his way home.
… more
Antwonlee23
My family has been coming here for a long time, however after tonight I don’t know if we’ll return. On Father’s Day me and my dad sat for 20 minutes without being even looked at by a server. Within five minutes of sitting a runner brought us bread, but after that no one came over. Didn’t even get a glass of water. 2 servers visited tables right next to us and didn’t even look over as we tried to get their attention. Food is normally pretty good, so if you’re set on coming here just do takeout.
… more
stephen honig
My only negative is that the pizza is too salty. I believe it’s in the sauce. I would like to keep buying my pizza there, but if you don’t adjust the salt, you will lose me as a customer.
… more
Susanne F
William accommodated us with just a few days notice for my sons first birthday luncheon (20 andults) after the weather ruined our original plans. He was a pleasure to work with. All of my guests have reached out since the gathering to rave about the food, service, cleanliness of the restaurant, and overall experience. Everyone’s food came out correct, hot, together, and was incredibly delicious. The portions were large so most of us have another meal for later on the week. I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant and strongly encourage you to go check it out! You will not be disappointed!!
… more
Christine Sposato
Last Sunday my husband and I were planning for takeout of a late dinner. So I called and checked the website, was very happy to see they were open till 10. I got to the restaurant about 9:30 to find nothing left except people cleaning up and an older man just saying they had nothing. Very disappointed and will probably not be back.
… more
Kathy Junge
Everyone there is so nice and accommodating. I guess there were other mgrs there before. But Everyone was so nice Jake was the man who greeted us I think he’s the new manager. Could not have been nicer ,explaining the menu to us Cappelli cakes were off the charts. Calamari not chewy at all.and the salads were crispy and delicious. Oh and the homemade cheesecake! Our waiter Jorge was so pleasant and accommodating. I really enjoyed the restaurant
… more
… View more