Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
126 Sunset Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 898-8300
Website: http://pizzacapemay.com/
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alysia Suarez
Went to this place yesterday and it was very small. The menu says we can order slices but the worker said they don’t do that, you can only order pies. One slice is $4 which is crazy because that’s more expensive than all of NY. We ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich and burger and it had no flavor at all and served on a roll. The burger was $8 and so small it was finished in 2 bites. The chicken sandwich was just spicy with no flavor. Would not return here, overpriced. It was $20 for a buffalo sandwich and burger, came with no fries or drinks.
… more
Jason Zahn
CASH only business but our pizzas and stromboli were tasty and everyone enjoyed them. Delivery time was very accurate and free (but please do tip those folks!). Pizza dough was on the crisp/ dense side compared to a NY style soft/chewy. Delivery did not include any napkins, parmesan, or pepper flakes. Not the best I’ve ever had, but solid food and overall pleased and would be happy to order from them again.
… more
Heather Pennington
Asked if they had personal pizzas. Register guy pointed to the menu in my hand, & sarcastically said, “Um no!” As if saying,” you have a menu don’t you!” That should’ve been my 1st & only red flag to leave!!!
… more
Billy E
Best $20 I spent in cape may, fresh hot and delicious pizza! If you are from north jersey you won’t be disappointed. Staff was so friendly too.
… more
Marian Raborg
Jake’s is the Best Pizza in Cape May. Great food especially the stromboli! Very friendly staff great service with a smile
… more
Pat Quinn
Really good plain pizza with good crust only a couple seats inside but some outdoor seating available. Wings are a good choice also.
… more
Bob Myers
Having lived the majority of my life in the New York metropolitan area, I was not excited nor had high expectations for pizza made with Cape May water vs. NY’s stellar tasting water, but I was so pleasantly surprised by the pizza Jake’s delivered to my resort room while watching over the wife who was feeling under the weather. Cheese and sauce were very flavorful and the crust really surprised me. Great job guys…keep up the good work!!
… more
Jared Cole
Got a large pepperoni on lunch and was blown away so for dinner I ordered a Philly chicken steak pie and just devoured it. Great service, brothers 2 right next door is not good at all, will always buy from Jake’s ,
… more
Jacob Stansbury
Great place to eat and get a meal and Angelo is very friendly and always serves good food!
… more
Steve “Kona Joe” DeWeese
The Philly cheese steak pizza and pizza fries were both excellent. There are three tables there but it’s made for take out and delivery.
… more
… View more