New York Style pizza crust with a variety of sauces and specialty pizzas. Specializing in Old World Style pizzas using sliced fresh mozzarella cheese. This pizza will remind you of a traditional pizza made in Italy. We use made in Wisconsin cheese for the traditional NY Style pizzas. All pizzas are cooked in a stone revolving deck, very high heat brick oven! Enjoy the bendable crust that has made New York famous in small town Wisconsin.
Based on 174 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
112 E James St, Columbus, WI 53925
Phone: (920) 350-0777
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Todd Coburn
I have ordered the Taco pizza, and this is my kind of pizza. I like my pizza little on the extra done side and they have not disappointed. Excellent service and fast delivery time. The whole crew does an excellent job. Already looking forward to my next one.
… more
Jenny Berghoefer
Columbus is lucky to have this place! My family stopped in for dinner. The food was delicious. We had a bit of a funky experience, because while we were serving up our first slices, the pan slid off the table and landed face down on the floor. 🙁 But the staff promptly cleaned up the mess and had a new pizza made for us. Then they comped both pizzas! Which was totally unnecessary but greatly appreciated. The pizza was amazing. Super good crust, fresh tasting sauce, generous, high quality toppings. We live in Madison, but I have a feeling we’ll be making the trip back to Columbus just to visit James Street Pizza.
… more
J LNJ
Ordered for pickup, great smilez ! My specialty pizza with wings was Excellenté
… more
Scott Mackiewicz
My new favorite pizza. The only negative is that we live 3 hours away. My wife and I try pizza everywhere we go and have had it all over the country and many places outside of it. I honestly can’t find one negative thing to say about the food or experience. We were driving back home from a family birthday party with our 3 young kids in the car and my wife suggested some pizza. It happened to be on our way home and they had easy online ordering. I figured we would be waiting a while but a minute after we pulled up it was ready. It only took 20 minutes for our 2 pizzas to be done. The 2 young ladies working the counter were fast, polite, and friendly. I grabbed some paper plates so we could go on with our road trip. The second I got back in the car and started plating up, I could tell I was going to be removing my belt on the ride home. We got a spinach ricotta pizza and a Good Fellas pizza, the latter of which I can’t say enough about. The sausage, ohhh the sausage. Handmade sloppy little pinched chunks that I love so dearly…firm, yet tender, flavorful and just the right amount of grease. The sauce is homemade. Somehow chunky yet smooth at the same time. More like a pizza/marinara hybrid bursting with flavor and color, beautifully balancing the amount and taste of the fresh slices of mozzarella. The roasted red peppers were a welcome addition of flavor, plump, juicy, and perfectly cooked. The garlic was sliced perfectly thin and cooked so they were somehow firm and crunchy, yet soft and smooth. The crust, I could have cried. It was firm, yet I needed to fold it in order to fully support my bite. The flavor punched me with a rustic fist. The chew….what can one say? It’s the kind that you need to give it a firm bite and tear, but it melts in your mouth. It’s firm, but soft. Delicate, yet chewy. It’s the absolute perfect crust. I want one big enough to use as a blanket so I can feel like those toppings must have…warm, safe, secure, protected, happy and home.
… more
Michelle Morris
Absolutely fantastic pizza! We had the one with sirloin and onion rings on it with this fabulous creamy BBQ-y sauce on a great crispy but soft hand tossed crust. Great service, very friendly and fast. The cheese bread is so delicious with the fantastic marinara sauce! I’d buy that sucks buy the bucket if so could!! So good! We will make the drive from the fox valley just for this food!
… more
Johnny Hanson
Holy moly! This pizza is amazing. I took my first bite of the pepperoni and it was an explosion of flavor in my mouth!!! I usually don’t like pizza, just had it at the party I went to, and I actually went for another slice!
… more
Joe B
Wonderful atmosphere. Excellent Service. The meat eaters pizza was the best I’ve ever had in 52 years. I literally teared up from feeling so happy! A++++++
… more
Andrew Burnett
Service was good. Staff was friendly. Had the Goodfellow, chicken bacon ranch, cheese fingers, 2 calzones, and old smokey. Old smokey and the chicken bacon ranch were the favorite.
… more
Allie Against The Machine.
Amazing pizza! I loved the crust and the sauce is amazing! The customer service is impeccable and very a fast service! I recommend you try this one of a kind pizza joint!
… more
E R
Fantastic food, my husband and I love their wings, and we have raved about their food to friends and family. My first sad interaction with them came from an order I placed just the other day.
… more
… View more