Jay’s Incredible Pizza is a pizza restaurant serving fresh and delicious food in Wilmington, NC. We use only the best ingredients to make an authentic and delicious pizza, serving our customers quality that they can taste in every bite. Packed with flavor and cooked with the utmost care and dedication to authenticity, you are sure to love everything about our menu.
Based on 92 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3600 College Rd A, Wilmington, NC 28412
Phone: (910) 791-7080
Website: https://www.jaysincredible.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Susan Evans
This was my first time ordering at Jay’s incredible pizza. First off I’d like to say the young gentleman that took my order around 12 noon on 8-24-23 was very polite and well mannered. When my order came up he offered to take it out to my car for me. Wow such awesome service. I ordered two pizzas, first one was, Hawaiian – the banana peppers and feta cheese. The second one was a large that’s incredible – the fresh garlic. Also an order pepperoni rolls with the marinara sauce. Everything was made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. I highly recommend Jay’s incredible pizza I took some pics to send to my son so he knew lunch was ready. I know I didn’t the lid off when I took the pic of the rolls but you can still see them.
… more
Kitona Renshaw
I’m not sure why they don’t have more reviews? This is the best pizza in Wilmington! Pickle pizza is my favorite but even the plain cheese is excellent, and that’s coming from a city girl. I would also recommend the Cesar solely based on the dressing. To make things even better they have a “pizza of the week” rotation where they experiment with weird toppings like jalapeño popper pizza
… more
Natalie B
This dill pickle pizza is, hands down, the best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life. Absolutely delicious… Or, dill-icious.
… more
Ashley Moore
The ordering process was easy and appreciate the fact they have a loyalty program for returning customers. After reading reviews saying the wings were drenched in sauce and cooked perfectly, we were sadly disappointed. They did not meet the expectations we had from the reviews. However, the pizza was delicious! No complaints.
… more
Steve Bentz
My wife and I usually order from Antonio’s but they put me on hold and I was on hold for about 5 minutes so I knew they were busy so I heard about Jay’s Incredible Pizza from my brother and he said he was going to try it one time, so I decided to give it a try myself. I ordered Friday night the 18th and I was very impressed with the delivery time and the pizza looked great! I even took a picture of it and texted it to my wife. I ordered it with 4 toppings, pepperoni, sausage jalapeños and green peppers. It was hot and looked fresh, but I need to be honest and I told them it was my first time ordering, but it really lacked flavor. There was hardly any sauce, each piece of my 18″ pie had only 2 pieces of pepperoni, one or two pieces of green pepper, one or maybe 2 jalapeños and maybe 1 or 2 small crumbles of sausage. Hardly any toppings, hardly any flavor and the crust was lightly browned on the bottom but wasn’t crispy at all like pizza crust! I have pictures on my phone…..it looks pretty good, but it didn’t even come close to Antonio’s, Elizabeth’s, Michaelangelos, Frank’s, Vitos, Pizza Hut, etc. Maybe more sauce, more toppings and cook your crust a little more, I don’t know, but the service was great. It was $32 for the 18″ pie with 4 toppings and I left a $5 tip to the driver, so it wasn’t cheap either. Sorry for the poor review but I want to be honest as I’ve lived here 24 years and eat at a lot of establishments.
… more
Donna Newton
I previously shared a poor review, but I was SO impressed to receive a call from the owner. He apologized for our experience and offered to make amends. This blew me away. I will definitely try Jay’s Incredible pizza again.
… more
Sportmom 222
You are right, Kitona R., Jay’s is the BEST pizza in town! In wondering why there aren’t more reviews, people are too busy eating their delicious pizza and wings to leave a review! lol. Don’t worry, it won’t take much longer and everyone will know that Jay’s Incredible Pizza is really incredible, and the BEST in town.
… more
James Jones
Normally great got the deep dish last night though I asked for well done dough still raw more than the normal deep dish the sauce tasted of pure salt and could hardly taste the sausage. Think it was just a bad night had it once before and was Phenomenal. OVERALL GREAT FOOD KEEP IT UP
… more
Dave
Jay’s came highly recommended,. and I was looking forward to a deep dish pie which I have not had in a long time.
… more
Mia Strauss
We had yummy pizza and tried the stuffed poppers. Everything was hot, crust perfectly cooked and delicious. Visiting from out of town we are always skeptical of a place that says they have the best in town, but I’d believe it. Staff was friendly too! We’ll be back next time we come to the beach.
… more
… View more