Neighborhood hub with wood-fired gourmet pies & other eats, with craft brews, many TVs & live music. Based on 40 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
704 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646
Phone: (201) 262-5600
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Helena Peacock
Attended Communion party in their private party room, accessible directly from parking lot. Quality of the buffet was well above what is often served at these type of affairs. Sausage & peppers were exceptionally good. Chicken, pasta, and salad were also very good. Staff were friendly & helpful. Really nice experience.
… more
dane lee
The pizza was worse than mama Celeste. It should just be removed from the menu altogether. I would go back to drink since they have $2 PBR’S and the wings are good. Some of the pasta dishes looked good but I haven’t tried any. I was expecting more since they own Sanduccis
… more
Don Baker
Second time I’ve been here for lunch. Second time I’ve had to send my food back to be reheated. Manager on duty both times seems bored and disinterested, as they don’t seem to do much lunch business. This is not the way to build it up. The waitress who took over my service was pleasant.
… more
Vincent Nicastro
I just had the worst experience for my first time at Jersey Boys. They brought my girlfriend the wrong meal. Two of the drinking glasses were cracked and the Manger could have given two sh!ts about it. Also their so called wood oven pizza is nothing but sauce and cheese on a giant cracker. I have had plenty of wood fire pizza and you can taste it in the dough. I would never recommend this place to anyone.
… more
Christopher Strobel
My fiancé and I haven loved coming here since we moved to New Milford almost two years ago.
… more
Aaron Forste
Just left with a party of 9. The 3 apps we ordered (calamari, wings and spin dip) were not good at all, the drinks came out bad and the sercice was awful. We saw our server twice in 30 a minute period. Instead of staying for dinner we left and i caught additude from my server when I asked to pay the bill (I guess she expected us to stay for more crap). The drinks at the bar before we ate were pathetic, the bartender was eating instead of serving me, the other was chatting with another customer, waited over 7 minutes for my second beer. Once we were sat, our server took an unreasonably long time to get our drinks, when the rest of our party arrived it was equally long. When we asked for water we got plastic cups with the comment “this isn’t too ghetto for you is it? Cause it’s easier for me.” We would’ve been happy with the cups without the commentary. One of our party commented on their drink being improperly made and instead of it being replaced a half cup of cola was brought to “cup it” with. We didn’t get app plates until about 10 minutes after the apps came, we had to ask for them. When we had the stack of plates dropped on our table and had to hand them out our selves, the third plate down was stuck, because it was covered in blue cheese (or some other washed on, cheesy substance). We would have commented and or complained about any of these but we never saw our server or anyone who resembled a manager, the place was very busy. My party and I all agreed that enough was enough and we wouldn’t eat dinner in this awful environment, and it was a friend’s birthday dinner. When I approached the wait station to ask for the bill, I was treated like I was doing something wrong, “I’m sorry, who are you? What table? The big table? Was something wrong?” I told her that the food was bad and the drinks were bad, she should have know that her service was bad. She didn’t care, clearly just didn’t wanna loose the tip for a dinner and more drinks from all of us. I paid it and tipped her the 20%. She never came to apologize, didn’t tell a manager how disappointed we were. We left, never to return, been telling two more friends this whole story while we order dinner at our next place so… 11 of us who will never return. I really hope that they improve or you are wise enough to stay away. Good luck.
… more
John
You people are out of your minds. The food here is legit. Wings are great, but the wraps, sandwiches, fries are awesome. Always a great beer selection too. If you’re hesitant because of the food, try it for yourself first.
… more
Karen Kasny
A lovely place for everyone. Jersey Boys has delicious food options and reasonable prices. Parking can be challenge on Saturday night, so it may be wise to allow some extra time for finding a spot.
… more
Albert Anderson
Great neighborhood pub with ample taps and liquor to whet your whistle. Food menu is solid. Best wings I have eaten in North Jersey.
… more
Jason Schweigert
Went here on accident, not where we planed to go. The menu was decent, service was great, but the decor needs some serious help. Will be back, nice alternative to other places in the area.
… more
… View more