Jersey Mike’s, a fast-casual sub sandwich franchise with more than 2,500 locations open and under development nationwide, has a long history of community involvement and support. Started at the Jersey Shore in 1956, Jersey Mike’s serves authentic East Coast-style subs on fresh baked bread – the same recipe it started with over 60 years ago. The company’s mission is to bring its customers the highest quality, freshest made sub in the industry and give back to the communities in which it operates.
New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings. Based on 85 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
444 NY-211 E Suite #6, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 386-7616
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jabari Buckner
The Girls this Morning did amazing I came during the big rush and despite the rude and nasty Customer in front of me The girls remained very calm and professional I Got a cold sub and the young ladies handled my food with great care I commend them 100% for Their amazing attitudes and wonderful demeanor while running a fast paced environment. The woman who was standing in front of me accused them of being unsanitary and I beg to differ they kept their area clean and I didn’t have to worry about any cross contamination. it pays to be nice and YOU LADIES DID OUTSTANDING ‼️‼️‼️
… more
Rachael p
I stopped here with my niece and nephew after a long day at Legoland for something to eat before a long drive home. I was greeted when I came in and staff was very friendly and patient with the kids. But, the thing that stuck out most to me was the quality and value of the sandwiches we got. I have been to Jersey Mikes in about 6 different states and I have never received a sandwich I felt was fully worth the cost until I visited this location. Most other locations serve very thinly sliced meats and it’s always a set amount of each meat on the Original Italian. I was shocked watching them make mine at this location and could tell right away it was made with more meat than ones I have had before. So I asked if this was made by slice or weight and they told me by weight. Mind Blown . I highly recommend this Jersey Mikes and my biggest issue is I don’t live closer to this one.
… more
Claire T. Wu
Go here if you want to feel good and loved and happy. The people here are angels and always so attentive and kind. It’s always sparkling clean and the team really works together to achieve high quality results for their customers. I am celiac and they always are so attentive to my gluten free needs and make an effort to really get to know their customers and their sandwich orders!!!! This place has changed my life! Thank you everyone who works so hard to prevent me from getting sick for just wanting a dang Sandwich!! You all are the best.
… more
Samantha B
I recently went in to this location to buy a sandwich. As soon as I placed my order I noticed that the young woman making the sandwiches was going back and forth from talking while holding a cell phone to her ear to then touching the bread and preparing sandwiches with the same pair of gloves on that she just touched the phone with. Totally unsanitary and just down right nasty in my opinion!! Imagine how many germs are all over that phone she just held to her ear and now you’re spreading those disgusting germs all over something that I have to put directly into my mouth ? Seeing this was definitely enough for me to just walk out empty handed. I definitely will NOT ever eat here
… more
Monica Rossi
I’ve been here quite a few times. The establishment is always spotless. The staff is friendly and professional always welcomes you as you enter. The manger is amazing. No matter how busy she is always smiling and acknowledging the staff and how good of a job they are doing as well as being hands on. She continues to talk to customers and when busy assists to move line along while apologizing for any delays. My go to spot. Keep up the good work. FYI. The sandwich’s are always large and delicious
… more
E
Whoever worked tonight was a bit heavy handed in the black pepper but overall the sandwich was delicious after I wiped off some of the pepper. I’ll definitely be returning to give them another try. I had the club sub which is my go to at any deli and I can’t wait to try their other subs.
… more
En Bee
I placed an order on the app for a Turkey club, no ham sub extra Turkey. Got the order; and there was 1 piece of bacon on each portion of the sandwich and when I say a total of 3 slices of Turkey for the entire sandwich, I’m not kidding. My husband got a Turkey and provolone and had heaps of Turkey. I asked him to go inside and get the extra Turkey. He was told that was extra Turkey. I could see the cheese through the Turkey because there was little to no Turkey. I then went in and asked for a for a refund because my sandwich was made incorrectly and to give the sandwich back. The girl at the counter was really rude. She asked which sandwich, I told her mine, then she asked how I paid I said through the app with Apple Pay. I put my phone up and “did the refund” I asked if it would email me a receipt and she said no it’ll be in my Apple wallet. I then asked for the manager’s information. She tossed me the card and very sarcastically told me to HAVE A GREAT DAY!!!! when I wasn’t rude whatsoever. Had I went in there yelling and demanding something, I had my husband ask for the extra Turkey; he was told no, and I went in and simply asked for a refund AND gave the sandwich back! For $10+ there should be more than 2 slices of bacon and 3 pieces of Turkey, especially you’re right next to Panera who has exceptional customer service. Not sure why the cashier took it so personally that I wanted proof of my refund but she had a nasty attitude and I definitely won’t be back to this location, we’ll stick to the Newburgh one. I was there at 7:40ish tonight July 22.
… more
Alexander Eurich
Jersey mikes on 211 definitely a better place then any subway I’ve ever been to. They pack there sandwiches nice and thick and are always happy to serve you, they are pretty quick too. I recommend the #8 with lays classic and lemonade, best classic lunch combo.
… more
Raphael Wedd
Hopefully they fired most of the staff since I went there last time. Waited an hour to get through the line and once I did, order was messed up, staff were standing around chatting and ignoring customers (as per so many other reviews on here) and food took ages to make as well as the fact that it just sat there and I had to ask for it to be handed to me twice so I could get out of there and eat my food. I’m pretty patient but that was another level of incompetence. Some serious quality control and training issues going on and it’s a shame because the food isn’t that bad.
… more
ADSY albert9y
The staff was pretty nice. Food was decent. Got the big Hakuna chicken and chipotle chicken wrap. One thing to note is that the wrap gets pretty messy and more soggy overtime, so I suggest eating hot wraps on the spot. Beware, there’s a LOT of juices for the hot subs.
… more
… View more