Jimmy John’s Menu – Pewaukee, WI

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Pewaukee, WI

Counter-serve chain specializing in sub & club sandwiches, plus signature potato chips. Based on 116 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 2.9 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Jimmy John's 53072

Address:
1890 Meadow Ln Ste. B, Pewaukee, WI 53072

Phone: (262) 574-9999

Website:

Hours

Thursday 10 AM–9 PM
Friday 10 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10 AM–9 PM
Sunday 10 AM–9 PM
Monday 10 AM–9 PM
Tuesday 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9 PM

Reviews

LS
We like JJ, but seriously, how hard is it to get a very simple order right? Today was dreadful! My husband went in ordered his, which was fine. All I wanted was a slim turkey with cheese added And we ask for extra turkey On the side. The guy tells my husband at the end you never ordered cheese. Yes he did! Whatever, I’ll add at home.

… more

DAN LADWIG
Placed order for delivery at 11:30AM, never came. Called at 11:50AM to check delivery status, phone rang and rang, nobody answered. Drove over at 12:15PM to find our group order sitting in 2 boxes behind the counter. Staff admitted they weren’t picking up the phone due to being short staffed. Did not offer any discounts or refunds. Cookies we ordered with the meals weren’t found inside the boxes. Never ordering from this location again.

… more

Lauren Kramer
I went for you know a sub. Walk in, no bread. I tried coming in last week. The ovens were broken. They told me to wait 10-15 minutes for bread to be made. There were 5 people in the back standing doing nothing instead of baking more bread. They are a sub place. Thats what they are meant to serve. And get this, one of the workers told me “I mean, there is a Qdoba right next door”. So now your driving me to another business? Makes no sense. No wonder you guys only have 1 star ratings. Will not be back.

… more

Shannon Kluka
If the staff was friendlier I would have given this place more stars. No greeting, not helpful and they looked like they hated their job. Sandwich was good. Only reason for the 2 stars.

… more

Gods Son
This location should be shut down, it is extremely unprofessional, the payment systems have been broken for a long time, there are often very long waits due to short staff issues. This location is damaging the Jimmy johns reputation

… more

Ron Marish
Have to agree with other reviews. This location should be closed. It is staffed by brain-dead automaton mouth breathers. Most jimmy John’s locations are well staffed and this one is a total sht-show.

… more

Kim Grunwald
Ordered online for pick up because delivery was not available but order was ready on time and everything was correct and it was a large order

… more

Chelsa Boyd
I waited an hour for my food, I started calling after 40 minutes. No answer in the phone. The food was eventually delivered and I told the driver it’s been almost an hour and I’m upset. He said sorry and ran back to his car with no explanation and I yelled out that I’ve been calling the store and he jumped in the car without responding. I still can’t get anyone to answer. Horrible customer service, extremely slow delivery.

… more

Arthur Brown
How do you forget the meat? Yes, seriously. Two of the three sandwiches I ordered (#12, #12, and a #14) were missing the meat. Over $30 for three sandwiches and a cookie, and two of the sandwiches don’t even have any meat?

… more

Dan Jensen
The subs were as expected and reasonably fast. The review is based on cleanliness. The toilet had a scum line and the sink looked comparable. That means they literally haven’t been scrubbed in over a week. There were no paper towels and two tp tubes on top of the full garbage. That doesn’t speak well of the hygiene of the restaurant. I would prefer to message corporate directly, but I couldn’t find a link for such feedback. There should be some accountability. I normally love Jimmy Johns.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions