New York-style pizza, subs & pasta provided in a quaint, family-friendly setting with a patio. Based on 129 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
943 River Rd, Granville, OH 43023
Phone: (740) 587-0046
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lynette Feliciano-Justice
My family loves the food, but I recently ordered a 16” white pizza ($23), 16” pepperoni pizza ($20) and a stuffed cheesy bread ($12). $55 for two pies and a side. Just can’t do it again. It’s way too expensive for pizza. We decided to make our own from now on. I love to cook anyway.
… more
James B
Visited Joe and Mimi’s for the first time and had a really great meal. The Gambler pizza was beautiful to look at but tasted even better. Reminded me of the pies I got when living in downstate NY. The salad was awesome. They seemed concerned about a recent price increase, but I found the prices very fair for the high quality received.
… more
Chiah Huff
Best pizza in all of Licking County. Huge plus is that they’re family owned and local. 100% recommend.
… more
Amanda Harrah
Little Slice of heaven in Granville Ohio..if you love NY style pizza this place hits the spot! You definitely want to give it a try and fall in love like I did!
… more
William Lalla
We moved to Ohio last November from New Jersey. Missing only one thing. An East coast pizza.
… more
Michelle Friley
Update…… This pizza is amazing every single time I have it . Want excellent pizza?? Come here. I’m a picky pizza eater. Joe and Mimis. Satisfies every pizza lovers dream. Real authentic pizza.
… more
Carmen Chan
Definitely one of the better pizzas in Granville. I wouldn’t call it New York styles cause it’s thicker but still delicious. We got the gambler and cheese sticks. Pricey for takeout pizza but well worth it. Would totally come back again.
… more
Stephen Burch
PSA: This is amazing pizza. Though I have some family members that did not care for it, I question their tastes versus the quality of food. Not very much room to dine in so plan on takeout. I would recommend as a must for local Granville Pizza!
… more
Justin Johns
I have really loved this place since I moved here but after tonight I’m very disappointed they must have been having phone issues I tried for over 2 hours and it would ring and beep that was it so I decided to drive there and order 640 pm I walk in and asked if they were having trouble with the phone the man said yes and I went to order and he was rude and said he wasn’t taking another order. Way to lose a faithful customer I really loved the mother but evidently her kindness doesn’t go to him.
… more
Éanna Bernini Cronin
Delicious spinach calzone, and the gamblers pizza is amazing. We got both to go, and they held up well to the delay before eating them. The dough is the perfect combination of chewy and crispy, and the topping was generous, and not as oily as what you get at some places.
… more
… View more