Based on 199 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
385 W Shirley Ave, Warrenton, VA 20186
Phone: (540) 347-0022
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Steven M.
Some of my favorite pizza ever, easily in my top 3. The Vinnie’s Favorite is so good I haven’t been able to try another pizza from there. I have however had the cannolis and those were excellent as well. I love this place.
… more
Brigid
The food was alright. Fried ravioli was by far the best thing we got! Our pizza looked sloppy, was missing signature ingredients and was cold. Our delivery took 25 minutes while we live 6 minutes from the place. Desserts were awesome, especially for the price!
… more
Jeff Davis
Wow, they have great pizza! Loved the Vinnie’s favorite, spinach and feta…. So good!
… more
Sarah Ratcliff
We happened to be in town and visited based on the reviews of how amazing the steak and cheeses were. While the fries were hot and delicious, the steak and cheeses were bland. The meat to bread ratio is off. So much bread with very little meat. My husband said his steak and cheese tasted like frozen steak-umm. I had the chicken steak and it was bland as well.
… more
E. T.
I went for the Calzone and Cannoli and was not disappointed. The Calzone was HUGE with plenty of cheese and pepperoni. The Cannoli was also a good size. The prices were more than fair and the staff were all kind and hospitable. Will definitely eat here every time I’m in town.
… more
Dawn Evans
These folks know how to do pizza. The routine is for us to place orders and pick them up about 30 min later. It’s worth the wait.
… more
Tammy Marie Coughlin Foley
Horrible experience through Door dash with this restaurant. Just order and take out. You can’t get a good delivery ever with this place through door dash. They need to stop and go back to delivery in house! Pizza was a mess the last several times we received it through door dash and everything is always cold. Not to mention the attitude with the delivery person.
… more
Lenny Campello
Super homey authentuc Italian tiny place… no dining in while we were there (due to insufficient staff), but super attentive and nice staff working the counter and the kitchen, with a nice, smiley old lady taking orders. Family is from Carini in Italy – Vinnie, the Sicilian-born owner is gregarious and friendly. Not your fancy food, but good, tasty, basic Italian food, although they have a larger than usual pizza selection! The calzones were huge! I ordered eggplant Parmigiana, which I hadn’t had since High School in New York City! It was a huge serving and as good as I recall from NYC. Easy in and out access from main thoroughfare at edge of beautiful Warrenton, VA. While we were there lots of locals picked up their phoned-in orders, so clearly, the locals like this cool joint. They had “battered cauliflower” on the menu, and I wished that I had ordered some! Finally… the prices were incredibly inexpensive! As though they were still in 1980 or so. Isn’t that the basic formula for a myst not miss place: Really good basic food, huge portions, friendly staff and incredibly low prices!!!! No wonder the locals like it so much! My highest recommendation possible.
… more
Jack Weddle
Great place for pizza, calzone, and cannoli. Order at counter and your order will be delivered to your table. Extra cost for drink refills and ice. Their dough is the very best. Servings are very generous. This is a must place to eat if you are in Warrenton.
… more
Doug Harris
Ordered a large Vinnie Favorite pizza tonight for dinner. It is the best pizza I have ever eaten. It is cooked perfectly with the crust golden brown, crispy on the outside and soft inside. The combination of fresh ingredients and a combination of cheeses made each bite a delight! Thank you! I stopped halfway through eating to make this post because it was so good.
… more
… View more