New York-style pies with specialty toppings & other Italian bites in a laid-back storefront locale. Based on 475 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
116 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840
Phone: (419) 427-5639
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lisa Isabella
Pizza is pizza but Joey’s sauce is the real winner. It has a bit of sweetness to it. Ingredients are a decent quality and a step up from a chain. As you walk in there is a cooler to grab drinks and dessert.
… more
Ellie P.
Delicious option for lunch or dinner on the road. I called to order when we were ab 25min away and when I arrived everything was ready, warm and tasting amazing. I loved that you can customize your calzone. Friendly and helpful staff as well.
… more
Brent Johnson
One of the best pizza places hands down! Fresh ingredients, and sauce is delicious. If in Findlay it is worth a try.
… more
JOHN Lane
If you are looking to order for dinner, make sure and order around breakfast. Do not expect any hospitality from the food industry when calling!! Short and rude! Once ordered a deluxe, all of the meats were cooked (thank god) but I think they forgot the veggies and threw them on once the pie was done!! Nothing better than a hot pie with cold veggies!! Decided to give them another shot. Placed order and we were told 1 – 1.5 hours for delivery. No worries… I will have a few cocktails and wait. I can appreciate it take time for good pie. 3 HOURS LATER… GIMME MY DAMN PIE!!
… more
kelsi saam
Literally one of the best pizza I have ever eaten.
… more
kbraker510
Hands down the best pizza in the Findlay area…They know how to make the perfect crust with freshest sauce and toppings. It is no wonder that are always busy. With the plethora of pizza places in town, Joeys stands tall on its product and excels at serving the customers.
… more
Daubs2 Daubs
Joey Fratello’s lived up to other reviews. Went for the first time, not the last. The calzone was excellent. Had Ricotta and the top crust was a bit crunchy with sauce on the side. Staff was nice and accommodating. Highly recommended.
… more
Clauswolfram
Pizza is good, will say that at the start. The delivery though, just pick it up yourself. Almost an hour and a half for delivery on a Friday afternoon, told 45mins to an hour. Didn’t get to eat any of my lunch before I had to work. Does reheat good, but so much better when it’s fresh. Third time this has happened, guess I’m a slow learner.
… more
Alisha Butler
I called at 5:06 and let them know I would be picking my food up at 5:45. When I arrived at 5:50, they told me it was just going in the oven. He said they got really busy after I called. But while I was siting in the store, someone asked an employee if it was busy, and he said, “Just a normal day.” After already experiencing an exhausting day, my food order was over 25 minutes late. I just wanted to get my food, go home, and relax.
… more
J Crawford
Has changed drastically over the past few months. So disappointing. Bone-in wings, which have been by far the best in town, were inedible tonight. The skin was like chewing on broken glass and chicken was flavorless. Pizza, which has been the best in town, is no longer. Crust has changed, toppings are now skimpy as is the sauce. I have been a regular but I guess that will have to change.
… more
… View more