Unassuming counter-serve pizzeria selling pies, hot & cold subs & other Italian-American dishes. Based on 500 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
201 W Harford St, Milford, PA 18337
Phone: (570) 296-2330
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nicole Pacella
I ordered an eggplant parm, meatball parm and a slice of chicken bacon ranch. When I got home I opened the container and noticed the sandwiches are like only 8 inches and $12! My eggplant was absolutely disgusting! It was mushy, no sauce and ABSOLUTELY NO TASTE! I called and spoke with a very nice girl and explained everything to her and apologized for calling but told her I paid a lot of money to just throw it in the garage. She said she understood and would get her manager. He was useless. He told me that everyone loves the bread and that the eggplant had sauce on it! I said not the way a “normal pizzeria” makes it. He advised that he can’t do anything without seeing the food. I told him I lived 35 minutes from Milford and wasn’t driving back there! He asked for our address and I told him if he can’t refund me to forget about it! I’ll take a loss and will never go back there.
… more
George
Pleasant neighborhood spot for an informal dinning experience. The counter staff is friendly, the variety of slice type’s tantalizing. My favorite is the pasta with broccoli and garlic sauce. The garlic is thinly sliced and plentiful. Way to go!
… more
Morgan Katt
A perfect place to pick up a Gluten Free pizza. The crust is fluffy and crispy and doesn’t fall apart. I am Celiac and I had no reaction. The young lady at the register (sorry I didn’t catch your name!) Was very knowledgeable and put up with all my questions. My non-celiac family also really enjoyed the pizza as well. They recommend the margarita pizza!
… more
Steven Koff
Have had pizza here before and it was ok. Tonight we ordered a veal parm sub and a chicken, eggplant, with roasted pepper panini. They were both mediocre at best with little to no seasoning on either and very bland. If there’s a next time I’ll stick to a slice only.
… more
George Benson II
The food was authentic in flavor and texture but for the price I think the serving size is a bit small . I also think that the flavor was very subtle and I personally prefer Pizza that has a more intense flavor
… more
Dajania Tireth
We were regular customers. We placed an order tonight for 1/2 regular pizza 1/2 with mushrooms and black olives. We also ordered an eggplant Parm, garlic knots, and poppers.
… more
Simone Passarge
I always love the pizza here it’s always soo delicious and the counter girls are always so sweet
… more
Diana Taylor
Great pizza, great service. Tried another place before it and they burnt our pie. Will always go to Joey’s!
… more
Ben C
Let’s just say this is the closest to Italian cuisine. Pizza is perfect crust ain’t dry or hard. Flavors are original.
… more
Devon T.
No frills delicious Italian American food. The portions are big and I love the pasta here. M The only con is that it takes so long to get your order. We waited well past an hour the last time we came
… more
… View more