Open 7 days a week, take-out, dine in, or have it delivered! Be a guest at your next party and let John & Mary’s do the cooking. Whether it’s a single sub tray, pizza, or large party package, John & Mary’s is perfect for business meetings, parties, tailgating and more. We prepare all of our food using the highest quality meats, cheeses, produce, and condiments.
Based on 676 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
6425 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043
Phone: (716) 684-4800
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: johnandmarysdepew.com
Reviews
Mary Fish
Family’s been coming here for years and this is probably the last for me. We called in a large order of 12 subs and only 4 of them were correct. 4 chicken finger subs and only one was right, the cheese was hard and dry and 2 hot were dry. Whole subs were only made as halfs and missing toppings as ordered. Definitely disappointed in this order from times past. If we hadn’t driven over an hour for the pickup I’d definitely be going back for a refund.
… more
Michael Wheeler
Surprisingly spectacular little place. My family got split up, half going to Niagara and stopped at the border so about 5 of us stopped here while we waited. We had some sandwiches, pizza and pasta. Its a simple place, so don’t expect much more than a tasty meal, on a paper plate, but we came away happy and full.
… more
J B
Great place to stop for a treat! You can enjoy a variety of hard ice cream or soft ice cream. They have a friendly staff with both indoor and outdoor seating. The pizza was average.
… more
Laural Anne MacGregor
Stopped for a quick bite while in Buffalo for a wedding. Royal subs were on the menu, which are my favorite. Since I was afraid of dripping mayo on my dress, I got a Greek salad instead, which was delicious. It had lots of warm chicken, and plenty of feta cheese. Next time, I will be getting the Royal! They also have loganberry, which is a treat for me!
… more
Jamie Pharoah
Vintage pizza & sub vibe. We ordered a Turkey BLT wrap and a chicken finger sub with curly fries to go. Waited about 30 mins. Close to closing and they had many customers still. Happy faces would definitely go again.
… more
Jennifer Newton
There were 2 waitresses at the counter when I came in for my pick up and one was friendly and sweet the other had a complete scowl on her face and was rude the times she did speak to me.
… more
katie miller
The sub rolls are terrible! Would be Sooo much better if they used a castanzo roll. And expensive! Won’t order here again not when buffalo has a million pizza places with great subs.
… more
Jeff Shearer
Pizza by the slice is horrible, it old and expensive. Toasted hoagie are not toasted(just the bread). I called ahead of time and asked these questions and nothing was the way I was told. I will not go back. 25$ for a sub and 2 pieces of pizza, nope save it. Wouldn’t of complained if it was good
… more
Brandon Lynchock
I see a lot of bad reviews, I am glad I did not share the same experience. The guy that gave me directions to the store was kind and patient, the store was clean (and had a cool Sopranos pinball machine) the prices are great, the wings were delicious and the staff Provided quick service. The only thing I noticed was that the garlic bread could use a touch more toasting. Ill be going back for more wings!
… more
Jeff Lee
Completely disgusting!!!
… more
… View more