Based on 418 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
5250 Old Charlotte Hwy # A, Monroe, NC 28110
Phone: (704) 774-1220
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gavin Mcmanus
Amazing food, and fast service! I had the pepperoni pizza and it was amazing, I also had the white pizza and it was okay but I don’t really like ricotta cheese. Food: 10/10, Service: 8/10, Atmosphere: 9/10, 9/10 would definitely recommend!
… more
Rogi
Think we found our new favorite pizza, not easy to find good NY style down here.
… more
Robin Caltagirone
So first off I want to stress that the food was great, the service even better.
… more
h busbee
Johnny tomatoes went above and beyond for my order that a food delivery platform really messed up. A huge shout out to Jen…she was awesome while we both tried to figure the mess out. No shout outs to the delivery agent who really wanted nothing to do with it, but refund 5 dollars on a 30+ order. I do still feel bad of the lost order that was made way before it should have and I hope my review helps others to choose johnny for the needs/wants of an amazing pizza experience.
… more
Alessandra DiNinno
Dough is good but I was not crazy about the sauce served with their rolls. The Margarita pizza was good though (different sauce)! Disappointed with the Nutella knots. The sauce tasted more like frosting than Nutella and the knots seemed microwaved as the dough stiffened up fast.
… more
DaCoda Hughes-Stille
Everytime I go , its always delicious and fresh!! I was a pizza man in New York City and this is another spot that tastes exactly like home!!! Highly recommend!!
… more
William Alford
Amazing! Can’t say enough about the amazing ownership and quality of food! You must try this for sure. We are going to be back for sure!
… more
Amanda Spoon
Food so delicious and I recommend you to check out! It’s very clean, the music is a great vibe and the customer service is awesome! Thank you Jennifer for your pleasure attitude and to the rest of the team -Thank you for great customer service! I’ll definitely be back! Sn: I ordered mozzarella sticks, garlic Parmesan wings and Stromboli ( black olives, onions and pepperoni) So delicious!! ❤️#TeamJohnnyTomatoes❤️
… more
Christen Ripoli – REALTOR
Johnny Tomatoes is really good, if a little inconsistent. We ordered a calzone tonight and it was overfilled with ricotta and just a tad cold in the middle. This Sicilian pizza was a different size than the one we ordered two weeks ago, even though they only have one size on the menu.
… more
Elicia Vignola
As a New Yorkers I’m not sure how other NYers like this place. I always judge a place by its Penne alla Vodka and it was so dry and just tasted like basil. I tried to mix from the bottom to get more sauce but it was very dry and tasteless all around. Buffalo chicken pizza was okay . The garlic knots might have given them from 1* to 2. They were full of flavor and just like NY. The rice balls was also extremely dry and chalky. My mom order Stromboli which was so greasy and hard to eat without 100 napkins.
… more
… View more