Based on 126 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
Address:
1085 Eaton Ave, Hamilton, OH 45013
Phone: (513) 737-8111
Website: https://www.karenspizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Claudia Steele
Slice’s were very small and green peppers were raw and thrown on top after it cooked. Very overpriced for what you get. Think I’ll stick with Milanos, they are over priced but at least it’s quality pizza with normal portion size.
… more
Jack Ciszewski
Chicken parmesan was cooked chicken chunks. No breading on it what so ever.
… more
Kurt Jack Berhalter
Our family has been going to Karen’s for years! Karen is not only a chef ,but a friend to everyone that comes in her restaurant! Karen’s roasted wings are the best around,you can’t beat them! The chicken Alfredo is awesome! The pizza,sandwiches,salad are good ,but Karen’s speciality items are the quality of an expensive restaurant! Thank you,Karen for the love you put in all your food!
… more
Ricky Nelson
One of the best pizza places around. I lived here for years before I realized that there was a pizza place close by. I decided to give it a try and I’m glad I did. Karen, the owner, is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. The pizza is out of this world!!
… more
Penny Brown
Must be an off night. Usually the food is good. Ordered 5 Pizza’s for a Birthday Party tonight and all very dry with no flavor..We just called another pizza place and ordered pizza. And someone from the back got upset over my sister asking for paper plates.
… more
Leah Garver
The garlic bread and cheese sticks didn’t have any flavor and just tasted like bread. Pizza was average (like Marcos or dominos), and the baked Ziti was just pasta with cheese on top. Not impressed. I would rather drive 30 minutes to Fratellis instead. Way better pizza and dinners.
… more
Ashlee Willis
Karen’s Pizza is amazing. This year, Karen put together pans of fettuccine alfredo for our family that we could bake ourselves on Christmas day. It was the perfect lunch! Thank you for everything, Karen!
… more
Elizabeth Lewis
We go to Karens on occasion and have yet to have a bad experience! Wonderful from the moment you walk through the door to the moment you leave. Some of the reviews I have read are very hard to believe after my experiences. I definitely recommend!
… more
Mike Coleman
Karens pizza is so good, I love their pizza and they also have some good other Italian dishes. Definitely the best in Hamilton. I recommend anyone who has not been here to go and try it and you will find a new gem.
… more
Jon Jackson
The staff is usually very friendly. The food is amazing and it’s such a great price! I would highly suggest to check out their weekly specials asap
… more
… View more