Based on 221 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
Address:
201 Main St, Preston, MD 21655
Phone: (410) 673-7333
Website: http://www.katiemaespreston.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Danny Smith
Update review a year later.
… more
Jeff Beall
I’ve been here a couple of times and I ordered something different each time whether I’m going for a burger and fries to pizza and wings this restaurant has really good food. I have liked everything I’ve had from here and plan on having even more they have to offer. Also the ice cream and milkshakes are great, sometimes I go there just for that. Can’t go wrong at this restaurant, the employees are also really courteous. After moving to Preston when me and my wife and food out Katie Mae’s is always my first option.
… more
RK Feury
We stopped in for lunch. We both ordered a pepperoni calzone. Oh wow! They both were piping hot and full of pepperoni, cheese and sauce! These are the best that we have ever had! Service and staff were both above par! We’ll be back on our next visit to Preston.
… more
Arleen Stader
Pleasant small town diner. But will be closing their doors for good on September 10th! A great loss to the community. Farewell and good luck! You will be missed.
… more
Joseph Whalen
The steak calzone was very good and my wife had baked ziti and it was just as good. I was not expecting the size of the full calzone. I was very happy with the staff and food I will be back soon to try more from this small home town business in Preston, MD. See you soon.
… more
Herbert Alton Coddington III
Food is not worth the price paid for it. I have a serious aversion to pickles, but everytime I specifically ask them not to add a pickle to my order, they lay it directly across my french fries causing my entire meal to smell and taste like pickles. Most of the staff I have dealt with are some of the most unfriendly people I have ever had to deal with in a restaurant setting. I would definitely suggest to not eat here if you want good service and good food.
… more
Ruthie and Chris Talkaboutit
Service was horrible. Our waitress came to our table with no enthusiasm what so ever. Very drab, I can’t even tell you the waitress name as we were never introduced. The food is ok, prices a lil steep for breakfast. 2.50 I think it was for home fries. We tried it two times. We wont be going back. What keeps them afloat…they are the only “place to eat” in that area.
… more
Josh Bergling
The food is good. 4 stars instead of 5 because it is near impossible to get through when calling between 11:30am and 1pm. The “welcome to Verizon wireless, the called party is busy. Please hang up and try again” message is very annoying.
… more
magnolia nelka
I wanted great pizza and I feel like that’s not what I got. Website looks amazing but pizza is just bland no flavor. I wouldn’t recommend this place if you want good good pizza.
… more
Danielle Zulauf
This is our third time ordering from Katie Mae’s and this is our third time having a bad experience. We’re new to the area and it is the only food place in town, so we wanted it to be good. The food has never been ready when they tell you, it’s always at least 30 minutes past the 15-20 they quote you on the phone. Then today when I got my pizza home, there was so much cheese and grease on it that you couldn’t even pick the slices up. The staff is always busy joking with their friends at the bar to properly take care of their other guests. The food is overpriced and mediocre at best. We have found it takes less time to drive to Federalsburg or Hurlock for food than to go to Katie Mae’s.
… more
… View more