Based on 66 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
Address:
128 E James St, Columbus, WI 53925
Phone: (920) 350-0750
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Katie Skuban
The food was delicious, but service was pretty slow. We were a party of 5 with a small child, which I understand may be considered a larger group, but we were the only ones in the place and some of the food came out lukewarm… that being said, the flavors were great and the staff was nice. The atmosphere is cute inside, with hand-carved and painted tables and chairs and Mexican music playing. I would eat there again.
… more
Greg Gracyalny
I came here for the first time in a recommendation for a business lunch. The restaurant is very bright and cheery with colorful seating and decorations. We were greeted and seated quickly. They brought out warm chops and fresh salsa right away. I had a chicken fajitas burrito and it was one of the best things I have had from a Mexican restaurant. Service and did prep was fast and efficient. I will definitely be back here again.
… more
Daniel Sullivan
One of the best restaurants in Columbus. Kids eat free on Mondays (kids meals seem to be good quality also), tacos are $1 on Tuesdays. Other specials the rest of the week. Food has all been good, free chips and salsa. Outdoor seating and festive atmosphere. Small bar but plenty of tables to drink at. Service has been very friendly, but maybe a bit more hands off than some people expect.
… more
Autumn Hammond
Absolutely love this place! It’s always busy so be prepared to wait for a table, and for your food too! But let me tell you: IT IS WORTH THE WAIT! I’m so happy LA Tolteca is in Columbus! We needed something good to eat!
… more
Tabitha Olson
Both the food and atmosphere were amazing! Prices were fair and it’s just hard to find a good authentic Mexican restaurant these days. We will be back every time we drive through town!
… more
Meng Gnav
The colors in this restaurant is awesome. I love all of the artwork on the tables and chairs. Enchiladas and chimichanga are my favorite. For some odd reason I fall into a food coma every time I come here.
… more
Katie Ryan
We love this place! We have dined in for lunch and dinner and ordered take out on many occasions! The food is quick and Amazing. It is messy Mexican food. ( the best in my opinion). Columbus needed this!
… more
Nick Staleos
The food was terrible. We ordered seafood chimmey changas and we asked for no peppers. When the food came it had peppers in it. It also had halepenos in it and the menu said nothing about halepenos at all. We also ordered 2 chicken tamales. They came with melted cheese on top and sause spred all over it. All the food tasted like it came out of someone’s butt. I CAUTION YOU TO NOT EAT HERE
… more
Matthew Dietzenbach
Great small Mexican restaurant. only downfall was the service was a bit slow when we were first seated. They also have a sister restaurant in Portage which is very good also.
… more
Cali Heavener Dunn
Love this place! Food so good and not too pricey! Great customer service as well. Eat here often ! Best place in our little town. YUM!
… more
… View more