A fish market & eatery with an array of classic American seafood dishes in a casual setting. Based on 497 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
4100 Monona Dr, Madison, WI 53716
Phone: (608) 467-9491
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
John Valenzuela
Nice start. Our table had lobster mac, Caesar salad and, the 4-Piece sampler combo along with clam chowder and the slaw. Overall, everything was very tasty, but I’d like to see less fried food. The service was excellent! The decor and atmosphere is great as well. Will come back!
… more
Barbara Gulten
Great new find in Madison for seafood. It’s hard to come by really fresh or plain good seafood. They seem to have capitalized on that and have it all.. for sale as well as sit down to enjoy freshly prepared. Didn’t care for the side salad, was at best mediocre. So you might want to stick to soups as a side. Great slaw.. crisp and not downing in mayo! The lobster roll and shrimp roll were very good; my friend loved it so much she ordered a deconstructed one to go! Oysters were fresh and maybe just by luck, but shucked well with no shell etc in brine. The owner/owner’s dad stopped by at tables to ask how people’s experience was and if they liked the food. They are located at a mini strip mall so there is nice easy parking up front. The atmosphere is casual with marine themed stuff on walls etc. Next time I will be testing out the tacos and few other things that look pretty good on that board, but only the mouth and gut will tell!!
… more
Sapphira L
Calamari po boy was lacking in sauce, bread was good. Fried calamari was tender and plentiful in the sandwich. Big portion of fries.
… more
amanda meyer
Fantastic food and exemplary service from Jeremiah! Came to town for a show and checked out this restaurant. It is beautiful and clean. Would strongly recommend. Had the oysters, mussels, onion rings, and hush puppies.
… more
michael orosz-fagen
Great staff. Good seafood. Well priced. Nice chill vibe. They offer a Sunday brunch from 10-2 with lots of nice options including eggs Benedict on seafood cakes for only 11.94. If you have dietary restrictions they have a lot of options. Whether you are gluten free, dairy free, vegetarian, or you have any other restriction you are sure to be able to find something to eat.
… more
Alexander Bajoon
First time walking in as it was my birthday and I was greeted by a man who gave us a run down of the food and explained that everything was fresh and each dish was prepared in kitchen. I decided to try out the Lobster Mac and Cheese and to my delight it was very tasty. The fries and onion rings were alright, and were most likely bought frozen and just cooked there. Overall, the experience was alright, but the prices were rather expensive.
… more
Alicia Hazen
Lake Edge Seafood is such a great addition to the east side! Their lobster roll is the closest I’ve gotten to the ones you can find in New England. Absolutely delicious. Love the Salmon Salad BLT as well, along with the clam chowder. We haven’t tried anything we’ve been disappointed with. Even the kid’s fish fingers are the bomb!
… more
Patrick Jones
New seafood restaurant in Monona. Food is excellent. Ambiance is very nice and service is good. The only negative thing is prices are a little high. Fish Fry Combo for $21 has 1 piece beer battered cod, 1 piece walleye, 1 pieces lake perch, 2 shrimp, fries, and a cup of soup,
… more
Brian Woodland
For what my wife paid for our meal, I am severely disappointed. Chewy fried seafood combo? Fries that were left in the warmer too long? Old fruit that didn’t even fill a third of the carry out bowl? $20/box.. And this was supposedly cooked while she waited… really bad 1st (and possibly last) visit.
… more
Jim Angus
Really good food. Went on a Friday night for takeout. Ordered for two adults and two kids. Wait was a bit longer than what I was told, but it was Friday night. Will definitely eat here again.
… more
… View more