Based on 387 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
150 E Geneva Square, Lake Geneva, WI 53147
Phone: (262) 248-5100
Website: http://www.lgpie.com/
Hours
| Thursday | 6:30 AM–6 PM |
| Friday | 6:30 AM–6 PM |
| Saturday | 6:30 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 6:30 AM–6 PM |
| Tuesday | 6:30 AM–6 PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jennifer Zablotny
You can tell it’s a “mom and pop shop” local favorite. All you need is a slice of pie, a cold glass of milk, and a bit of country music to give you a lil bit of that ol’ American country morning. Thank you to Lake Geneva Pie Co for giving us a great wake up to celebrate a special day!
… more
Carolina Alvarado
Delicious pies. Our servers were a couple of elderys and couldn’t be better, there were so sweet and kind. Definitely we’ll comeback.
… more
James Reuss
Be prepared for crusts of every kind – quiches, pot pies, fruit pies, cream pies, cheesecakes and more. And espresso drinks! You can watch the crusts being rolled so you know these beauties didn’t arrive on a freezer truck. We could barely scratch the surface of the many pie tins but everything we tried was above average.
… more
Kimber Kaya
Cute place. Slow service. Great pie! I would have liked to see prices and pies available by the slice on the chalkboard. Only prices advertised were the beverages and a price on a whole lemon meringue pie. After purchasing 2 slices, I’m guessing it’s about $5/slice.
… more
James Wernicke Sr.
Delicious. We had raspberry pie, raspberry orange muffin, chipotle cheese quiche and oatmeal cookie. The quiche and baked items were nice and moist.
… more
Stephanie Crain
Wonderful friendly staff, amazing assortment of pies to choose from, soups and quiches also available, delicious as they look! A must stop if you are in the area! Best chocolate cream pie I ever had!
… more
John Cadwell
I called at 11:00 asking for a banana cream pie and was informed they had none. However, they indicated they would bake one and have it ready by 3:00. I ordered two and arrived an hour early and found the pies ready to go ( I picked up a key lime pie in addition). Without a doubt, it was the best banana cream pie I have tasted. Combined with the terrific service, this is a marvelous shop. My first visit, but I will be back soon.
… more
Phillip Grønvold
An amazing hidden jewel in beautiful Lake Geneva. Super friendly, family run, everything made from scratch, and their award winning pies absolutely live up to the hype. They must make hundreds of pies everyday. The line is usually out the door. So if you want to get your favorite pie come early, or order ahead.
… more
Frank McNeff
My wife and mother in law love this store. Every year we visit Lake Geneva. Last day always stop at pie co. Love the pies and quiche.
… more
Laura Tobon
Overpriced for average food. We had beef barley soup which was 3/4 barley and quiche which had undercooked crust. Will not go again. Also purchased a small 5 inch pot pie for $11. Probably not worth it.
… more
… View more