Based on 61 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
23 Crestwood Rd, Lake Huntington, NY 12752
Phone: (845) 932-8131
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 1–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Craig Snedeker
First time here, ordered online and picked up. Went very smooth and everyone was nice. We got pizza, a stromboli, garlic knots, and chicken and fries. Everything was pretty good and reasonably priced! The fries weren’t great and the stromboli was a little undercooked but we enjoyed it and I would come back.
… more
Gordon Shumway
Stopped for dinner. Food was awesome and staff was great. Chris was at the bar and took our order. What a great guy. Went out of his way to make us feel at home. You could tell he’s been taking care of people for a long time. He instantly made us feel like we’ve known each other forever. We ordered the chicken parm and eggplant parm meals and a pizza pie for the kids. Everything tasted amazing and the portions were huge. After attending a local show we came back later in the evening for drinks. When we arrived back they were having a party for the owner and immediately offered us and our kids cake and made us feel welcomed. The place has a real local feel but the staff and customers all make you feel like you are at home. It’s a good place to get a cold beer, have a dance on the dance floor or just have a good conversation. Everyone was super cool and the view of the lake is worth the price of pizza.
… more
Alith M
I called half-hour before closing. The woman was patient as I decided and then changed my order. They were friendly when I arrived. The food was fresh and delicious. The salad was phenomenally fresh. I loved it.
… more
Gianna Scarantino
Unfortunately can’t even give a review on the food because the second my friends and I walked in, we were sexualized and called derogatory names by a male customer in there. The comments were loud enough that other customers and the bartender heard. Yet no one stepped in. We decided to leave after the gross comments were made. As we were leaving, the man who made the lewd comments followed us out to my car. This was just an unsafe and creepy place to go to. If you’re a younger female, please avoid this place. I’m really disappointed the staff didn’t even step in when we were clearly getting harassed and chased out to the car by a perv.
… more
Justin Goldman
We stopped by this place on our way back from the Catskills. Really nice view plus amazing pizza. Honestly the best I’ve had in a good while. Crunchy crust, generous amount of sauce, perfectly melted cheese that slides right off (in the best way).
… more
Alz Ross
Amazing pizza! Christine went above and beyond to be sure all my needs were met
… more
Stacey Burt
Yummy pizza. Took a long time to get out but cool area to sit, dance and play
… more
Jesse Schurmann
What an amazing pizza joint with friendly owners and a cozy neighboring hotel! We loved our stay during a trip for a nearby concert at the center for the arts, and the Lakeview Pizzeria & Bar provided us with an incredible feeling of “home” as we returned each night. I would recommend everyone visiting to grab a delicious slice and pie from here and stay at the neighboring hotel! Both very amazing owners and establishments!
… more
Joe B (Joe)
Very good food, a bit pricy but the portion sizes make up for it. They are on the Slice app which makes ordering very easy. I haven’t dined in, but the pizzaria/pickup area is clean and well maintained. The ladies running the place are very nice. The only downside is that you need to allow a little extra time for larger orders than you might for a comparable shop in an urban area, but not an onerous amount. I hope we’ll have a long and happy business relationship.
… more
Will B
The best Sicilian pie I have ever had. This is coming from someone who lived in city most of life and had access to the best pizza in the world! The crust is phenomenal, thick, crunchy outside, soft inside. It gets a really nice char around the sides, but not burnt. They also put garlic in the pan and it cooks into bottom of crust. The sauce is great as well. Has chunks of tomatoes, thick, but not too sweet. As far as the cheese, it’s obvious they use a high quality mozzarella, not oily like the places that use cheap mozzarella. This pie easily feeds a family of 4 to 6, it has 12 slices. Definitely give it a try!
… more
… View more