Based on 17 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price
Address:
1600 W Market St Suite 2, Nappanee, IN 46550
Phone: (574) 773-4188
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kim Holladay
We really enjoyed our experience here. The staff was very friendly. The atmosphere was peaceful and relaxing. The food was very good but could have been a bit warmer. The harvest salad was so good. I could have eaten a huge bowl and been done. Delicious! I had broasted chicken. I agree with others: it didn’t have much flavor (except for the skin). The brisket was very tender and lean. Mashed potatoes and stuffing were the best. I usually eat cornbread stuffing now that I live in the south, but the “white bread” stuffing was a delicious reminder of my days growing up in Indiana. We had lemon meringue pie. The meringue was high, light, and tasty. The lemon layer was a little too much like lemon jello. But I ate it nonetheless :). I would definitely return!
… more
Gary Mosher
Sorry I tried to like this place but it is a ghost of its former self. The last two times I have been there the food is cold. Fried Chicken, mashed potatoes and gravy and green beans all cold. Not worth the drive for $20.00 a plate. Everything else is extra, no salad, no bread. Service is friendly. The pie tastes like it was store bought. The bakery is gone too. And they have muzak for music UGH. I have written to the website/management to complain but never received a response so they evidently don’t care. This place is nothing like it used to be. The only food item from the original Amish Acres is the threshers dinner which is now called the Farm Feast. Everything else on the menu is like upscale food. Amish Acres restaurant RIP.
… more
Gary Reynolds
Great building and solid staff.
… more
Jonathan Kitchens
Incredible Brisket and Catfish! The Farm Feast was a feast indeed. The cheesecake is awesome. So far the pot roast, brisket, catfish, and broasted chicken have all been delicious.
… more
Daniel Kravitz
This was an exceptional restaurant when it was part of the former Amish Acres. It is now just sad and pathetic. Their web site doesn’t match the menu. The menu is also wrong and has not been updated. The waitstaff was clueless. The food tasted like it came from a box. Please save your time and money and eat elsewhere.
… more
Russell Prichard
Been coming to this place for well over a decade and it’s just not the same. Seems like they’re trying to make this place a little too upscale. This is supposed to be an Amish experience but when you have Run DMC playing in the barn it kind of takes away from it. Maybe they’ll figure it out before we come back next year, hopefully not for the last time.
… more
Tim Reece
What a perfect place to spend time with your Family or friends over a meal. The food is Delicious and prepared very well. The service is excellent. We found our new favorite place for Sunday brunch.
… more
Emily Holtz
Very good food and great service! Definitely recommend!
… more
Sara Patta
Had the Chop Salad! Wonderful ambiance.
… more
Theresa Barnett
The chicken dinner is amazing and the omg that cheesecake!!!
… more
… View more