Based on 201 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1001 Vincennes St Suite 100, New Albany, IN 47150
Phone: (812) 725-0021
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sherri Abromavage
Server was just slightly overwhelmed by our large party, but she strove for good service. I had the Italian sub and my husband had a meatball sub. We shared an appetizer with others and get to see and smell their pizzas.
… more
Katie Phillips
Honestly, we think this is the best pizza in town. Great pizza starts with the crust — Legacy’s is flavorful, crisp and chewy at the same time. The sauce is not overly sweet like you’ll find with lower quality ingredients, and the cheese blend is delicious. Every topping we’ve tried so far is fresh and tasty, and the Bacon Jam pizzatizer is DELICIOUS.
… more
Donald Mansmann
Great! We all ordered pizza (8 of us). Everyone raved about how great their pizza was. Our server was especially great. When the check came, we were all shocked by how reasonable the prices are. The only slight negative is how long it took from when we ordered until when the pizzas were brought out. But, the wait was worth it.
… more
Chris Abromavage
To be fair I was with a party of 13 people and I think they may have been a bit overwhelmed by the size. None of the staff seemed to be over college aged. Having said that the place was clean and smelled divine. The food was attractive and quite tasty. I’d like to give them another shot with a few less people in my party. I had a large meatball sub and my wife got a large Italian sub. Both were very good and more than either of us could eat in one sitting. The sandwiches came with chips and some spicy little peppers. Some of the other people in our group ordered different pizzas and they all looked great.
… more
Basil Vansuch
Yummy pizza! Service was fast and staff were very nice. Pictured is a three cheese pizza with mozzarella, Romano, and feta.
… more
Miss B
First timmer… came in on a whim for my lunch break. Did not disappoint! Hands down, one of the best calzones I’ve ever had. (Pro tip- They’re a dollar off on Tuesdays). Madison was also super friendly and helpful. I look forward to coming again to try some of their other menu items.
… more
Jeff Winkler
Have been a regular customer for quite awhile and order almost every week. Pizza, Strombolis, and everything else they serve is fantastic. Very consistent, staff are all very friendly and prices are reasonable. Can’t recommend enough, one of the best pizza places in S Indiana.
… more
Joe
Excellent pizza and service! Had the Classic Pizza and the Nonna Pizza, both were fantastic with plenty of flavor and that nice crunch with the crust. Will visit again!
… more
Barbara Hudson
I’m from Wisconsin visiting here. My sister told me before I even came here we had to go to Legacy. It was wonderful! Quaint and cozy and the spaghetti marinara was great. We have decided we have to go back for a pizza next. Lovely place, wonderful service and such a really nice server too.
… more
Mrs Thacker
We had the bacon jam pizza and the Stromboli. Everything was delicious! Our waiter, the owner’s son, took really good care of us. We’ll definitely be back!
… more
… View more