Guests move between an adjoined upscale American restaurant & a casual sports bar with 200+ beers. Based on 530 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
835 1st St, New Suffolk, NY 11956
Phone: (631) 734-5123
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
Christopher Artibee
First time here and so glad we came. Food and service was phenomenal! We had the wonton special for an app that was so delicious. I had seafood stew which was packed with flavor. All the various fish and shellfish were cooked to perfection. You could bottle the broth! Wife had the short ribs which were amazing so tender and delicious. The drinks were made perfectly and well balanced. The fresh made rolls were piping hot and so good! We will be back.
… more
John J Van Vuuren
Food was excellent and the atmosphere was delightful. Great choice for when you’re on the north fork and would like a bit of fine dining. They also have a bar section which is alot of fun if you just want to have a drink and watch the game.
… more
Len James
I’ve been going to Legends for the past 20 years. I usually sit at the bar with my wife and enjoy the beer selection and a good lunch menu. I see many folks enjoying the dinning areas. I don’t comment on food because its a matter of taste but I’m never let down.Legends is a nice place in a great part of the north fork.
… more
John Guma
Very nice diversified menu containing steaks, seafood, vegetarian specials, chowders and some excellent starters. Large selection of draft beer and and ample wine list. The service is first rate, friendly and efficient. Nice selection of deserts and coffee. Give Legends a try.
… more
Gwendolen Groocock
Our go-to for a casual dinner at the bar. Service is thoughtful, and rarely slow except at the busiest times. The staff makes us feel special, and are very responsive.
… more
Adam Bundy
The food, the staff and the experience were all increbile! Thanks for an amazing dinner
… more
Howard Gould
Excellent Customer Service and the food is above and beyond fantastic. I reccomend the fresh grilled tuna sandwiches and all the salads are A plus. Legends is facing beautiful outdoors and the inside and amazing. The desserts on the menu are great. Also, parking is easy to find and reservations are highly reccomended.
… more
Kyle R
I’ll start by saying the food is decent. Some warm bread and butter to accompany the pasta would have been ideal. The reason for the 3 stars is primarily because of the service…or lack there of. I was seated outside given water and immediately gave my drink and food order. My drink came 15 minutes after ordering. When it was delivered to my table I asked for a water refill. I never saw the water until I asked again once my pasta was brought. The pasta was brought 30 minutes after ordering. I ordered a side salad initially but when the pasta came I was told “Sorry, I forgot to tell you we don’t have side salads but you can order an entree salad”. I might have done that but figured it would have been another 20 minutes for it to arrive. The host brings me my pasta but never the utensils to eat it with. He apologized, brought more water and a knife and said he forgot the fork. Fork finally came, like I said, pasta was decent. The entire time, the host on the other side came out to ask 4 times how everything was, my host was a ghost. Unfortunate as I wouldn’t mind coming back for the food but good service is just as important. Oh, after waiting and waiting I went inside to pay because the check never came out. The host was just standing inside!
… more
Queenie Bee
The two stars are for the great service, the wonderful atmosphere, and the beautiful location.
… more
Brad Ascalon
Went this evening for dinner. The chicken meatball appetizer was terrible and overpriced. The coconut curry salmon was flavorless. The waitstaff was friendly but extremely slow. And what place in its right mind needs that many televisions hanging on the walls? I know the north fork doesn’t have that many restaurants to choose from but you gotta do better than that.
… more
… View more