We are proud to have served New York Style Pizza to Overland Park for the last 40+ years. We have a great salad bar, where we can build you a salad, and an extensive list of sandwiches and pastas. We are still owned by the same family and look forward to continuing to serve Overland Park and Kansas City.
Counter-serve pizza parlor serving up New York-style slices, pies & subs since 1978. Based on 593 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
11134 Antioch Rd, Overland Park, KS 66210
Phone: (913) 451-9245
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Key
They’re pizza is so good! I just wish there was one closer to me and they weren’t so expensive but I suppose it’s worth it!
… more
Andy Crow
Stopped in for a late-lunch slice with my son. Really great NY style pizza. Good variety of toppings ready to go by the slice. Bright, clean tasting tomato sauce, quality toppings and the crust is lights-out.
… more
Josh Edwards
They forgot our mozzarella sticks. Nobody knew how to refund the item. On the good side, the pizza crust is amazing.
… more
A MB
Ate here during a futsal tournament. Pizza slices are fine if you get cheese or pepperoni but if you go fancier it’s no bueno. Went to use the bathroom and saw a cockroach holding onto the door frame so, not gonna eat here again. Giving 2 stars because the chairs are dirty but it’s trying.
… more
Tiffany Jamerson
Soooo I been meaning to post about this spot but I’m glad I waited. Anyone that loved Orignal Pizza in Bannister Mall back in the day will TRULY appreciate this place. Pizza is excellent and takes me back to my mall days for sure. The staff is awesome, real nice and helpful, good recommendations if your unsure. Been about three times, trying different slices. I LOVE the variety of slices, calzones, sausage rolls, and strombolis, amazing! Tried a Greek salad, soo freaking good. You won’t be disappointed at all, plus they have some cool old school arcade games, an ol school action figure display case and some good ol cold beer selections. You can’t go wrong here, hands down!
… more
Tiffany Sharp
This is by far the best pizza place I’ve found around. You can order by the slice. They have a wide variety to choose from. Pineapple ham. Cheese. Mushroom. Supreme etc.. You can also order a whole pizza. They have a great salad bar with a wide variety of toppings. Made to order. Prices are very reasonable. For a family of four we ate for under $25. We will definitely be back for more! NY style pizza at it’s best.
… more
John “Dabronxbadboy” Gleeson
Being from NY I’m always curious when I see pizzashops advertise as New York style, but this place actually comes super close. They have pizza by the slice and a vast variety of different topped pies ready to be sliced up. The pizza was good and it did start off by tasting very much like a slice from the big apple, but after finishing the slice it left a slight after taste in my mouth that wasn’t necessarily bad but it made the experience different if that makes sense. So I’ll still recommend others who are looking to enjoy some good pizza here, it just missed the mark by a hair.
… more
Lynn L
Not only did I get my heavenly authentic NY pizza, but he went above and beyond in making me zepolle (not on the menu, totally made my day). The service was amazing, place is nice, clean and super spacious. The staff is amazing and totally adds to the feel good experience. They even have a video game arcade which just adds to the real feel of a NYC pizza shop. This place made me both homesick and happy at the same time. After almost 3yrs in KC, I finally found a pizza shop that hits home and heart for me #iminlove #thisplacerocks #leonespizza #happynewyorker #cuzarealNewyorkerknows #realNYCpizza
… more
Lauren Ciambriello
Coming from NY I’m always on the search for NY style pizza. I figured I would give this place a try. I ordered a large Stromboli pizza, BBQ wings and a calzone. The pizza was overpowered by sausage (which is good if that’s what you like) it didn’t taste like real NY pizza but it wasn’t bad at all. The wings were good for being from a pizza place. They didn’t have garlic knots but the guy behind the counter said he could make them real quick which was nice. A large pie 3 toppings, wings, calzone and a 2liter came out to about $45.
… more
Royce Rogers
The chicken parm pizza roll (stromboli/ calzone) I ordered online came as just chicken parm. I can live with that but the grilled chicken chunks were lackluster and served in very watery sauce. My wife pizza was really good on though. Hopefully you get what you order and its pizza/calzone, leave the pasta for some other time.
… more
… View more