Based on 116 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
5335 NY-23, Windham, NY 12496
Phone: (518) 734-4900
Website: http://lillyssteaks.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–11 PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–11 PM |
| Friday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 PM, 4 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 4–11 PM |
| Monday | 4–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sherly Lucien
Im very picky about my food. I had the red snapper over spinach. My food tasted very much homemade and satisfying.
… more
JC Cantrell
Wife picked this place because we were staying nearby.
… more
David Hatch
Beautiful place, was nice out, went to have a puff, and noticed that the back deck was a great place to have a nice dinner outside. Our waitress and busser, I believe, were pleased on how things went, and are going to start dining out back when the weather cooperates, of course. The brook next to the back decks was a nice addition…
… more
Joella r
Nice place. Professional and fast service. Hostes seated us right away. Steak and duck was cooked perfectly.
… more
Phoenix Feathers
We really loved this place. It was a slow Sunday evening, and we had choice seats. Fran was attentive and friendly. The food was killer! Huge portions, cooked perfectly. Our drinks were great too (from the $15 cocktail menu) so kudos to the bartender (who was the busiest). Great experience.
… more
Epicurean Chichi
Lilly”s steaks & Co formally known as Prime, was a mixed experience, dining room was decorated in adirondack ,a bit dark. Need a bit renovation to bring into modern times. Wait staff Fran was extremely professional,until end of meal,disposition changed ,seems a bit understaffed. We ordered dry age beef 30 days 23 oz bone n strip medium rare,and one medium,simply tender with notes of velvet like texture. Also ordered double cut charred pork chop, which was a disappointment, it was overcooked, ordered medium, very bland and should have been charred more than looking at a beige piece of pork. Calamari was light and flaky with hints of peperoncini which balanced the fried squid.long island mussels with hints of white wine tender and delicious. Side’s of Mac n cheese was a miss,extremely bland and a bit undercooked too pasty, side of rice was undercooked, mash potatoes could have been served in bigger portions,onion rings and French fries a bit overdone , cooked in same old oil ,taste of oil is never pleasing to the palette. Lilly’s has an extensive wine list nice labels available. Ordered the Stella Artois beer served in a brandy snifter,very odd,small portion for the price. In today’s economic turmoil of recession, clients can be choosy about the eating establishment, other than the side accompaniment pitfall, you want to try a delicious tender dry aged steak, one thing this place is understaffed and when waitress hands you the check she leaves immediately due to attending to two other tables,this establishment charges a credit card fee ,without telling you ,no other premier establishment charges clients for credit card fee,at best they are happy for your patronage.If you try Lilly”s formally known as Prime in Windham N.Y. your palette is sure to leave a lasting impression. Beware of hidden service fee without acknowledgement from staff. $$$$
… more
Darya Raev
Very nice and cozy place . Wonderful food . 3 stars because somehow they charge us 10$ for sharing plate . Which was ridiculous in my opinion. My husband was eating all dishes and I only had bites from his plates since I’m not really eat after 6pm. And for that we had to pay additional 10$. And they never mentioned that while we were ordering . Plus additional 4.56$ if you pay with credit card, which is also not cool.
… more
Kelsey Gittler
I’ve eaten here a few times and the food is great but i wanted to leave a review to comment on the great customer service. I wanted a gift card and reached out to see if it would be possible to receive it by mail before a certain date. The owner wrote back to me immediately and had the gift card mailed out to me the same day. I really appreciated the prompt attention and service! Looking forward to visiting and eating here again soon
… more
BATZARRO209
Steak was cooked just right, and potatoes and veggies were tasty. Expect to pay a premium as the area is on the mountain, but it is totally worth it if you are on vacation in the area and looking for a hearty dine in meal.
… more
Denise Cooper
Food and service were pretty good. The restaurant is very dark. The prices were ridiculous. My entree was $46 and didn’t even come with a vegetable. No salad or soup either. The bread was something I can get at my local pizza joint. My silverware was dirty. Not what I expected from these prices.
… more
… View more