Based on 237 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4511 John Tyler Hwy Unit C, Williamsburg, VA 23188
Phone: (757) 259-7955
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Seth Marks
This place has New York style pizza slices and 2 slice lunch specials. But let’s get down to the meat and potatoes of this meal,we started with piping hot garlic knots followed by a perfectly cooked and stuff meat lovers calzone. The crust was nice and crispy not over cooked or burnt. We also ordered the veal marsala. The pasta was cooked perfectly slightly Al Dente ,the wine sauce was delicious and the veal was nice and tender. Saw this place on Facebook even though it was a 40 minute drive well worth 10 out of 10 For a little mom and pop place limited seating 5 tables mostly to go. In the 40 minutes we sat eating I roughly saw about a 80 pizza picked up.
… more
Darren Keithley
We loved the NY slices! There was enough variety of pizzas for everyone to get what they wanted. Very friendly and the pizza was so good we went back the next day (days 1 and 2 of our three day vacation)
… more
Molly Magyar
Listen the pizza here is the average experience, it’s a very predictable taste, a very classic pizza, dough is bitey and the sauce is very good not too chunky, perfect amount of cheese and toppings. But the wings? The wings are the best things that have ever graced my lips. My advice. Get the wings with the sauce on the side and extra crispy especially if you’re picking up your order. The buffalo is not too spicy and has a great flavor. Get the garlic knots and add the vodka sauce for dipping. A heavenly experience.
… more
Charley
small place, but don’t let that fool you. came last year and tried the Chic Fil A pizza, and have officially made it a tradition!
… more
Jackie Berberabe – Real Estate Agent
This is our go-to NY Style pizza place. Because I don’t eat any meat, their Margherita pizza is what I order for my husband and I. Our boys like their Meat lovers pizza, the buffalo wings and of course the “must have” garlic knots. So delicious! I do like to reheat my pizza in a pan because I like the crust a little crunchier. The large pizza is huge btw.Usually ready in 20-30 minutes so we always call ahead. It smells so good in the car that it’s hard to resist eating on the way home. Very nice folks too.
… more
Danay Escanaverino
Not really a good dine-in option but if you are picking up or getting delivery, then you owe it to yourself to try this place. Great NY style pizza, with by-the-slice options. The garlic rolls are pure awesomeness and the calzone is also really good. We have ordered probably 20 times and never had less than great food. Also, staff is very friendly.
… more
Patricia Shaffer
Great New York style pizza! The large Hawaiian pizza we ordered had a tangy tomato sauce and an excellent tasting crust. Our desserts of cheesecake and cannolis were straight out of the freezer but also tasted good.
… more
Morgan Ringwald
Worst service ever, and now they’re sneaking in “support local” fees on online orders AFTER you submit payment. It just shows up on the receipt in your email, not the checkout screen.
… more
Ana Locklin
I’m visiting from California and saw little Charlie’s Pizza on Facebook. I was under the impression that it was a larger restaurant. It was a small place in a shopping strip. A whole pizza seemed a bit expensive to me. They had a lot of pizzas that were already made, they did not look fresh to me. Basically they got a cheese pizza slice and added the toppings that you wanted and warmed it up for you. I was also hoping to have a beer and they did not serve any alcohol. I don’t think the air was working because my son said it was pretty warm. I ordered two slices of pizza and asked for pepperoni and mushroom. They gave me one slice with pepperonis and another slice with mushrooms. That’s not what I had in mind, but I ate one of the pieces and took the other piece to go. I won’t be back. I’ll try other pizza restaurants in the area.
… more
Patricia Urso
This New York style pizza was good.They advertised 1.75$ per generous slice.They have a selection of certain topped pizza slices for that price.If you ask for other toppings on your slice,they charge .75$ per topping.I ordered sausage and mushrooms and my slice cost 3.50$ They offer pepperoni,basal and mozzarella,Hawaiian pineapple for 1.75 All and all their 18in pizza is 20$.Much better than Bellisimo for 6$ a slice.Guiseppi’s Pizza has a 6 slice generous slice with 2toppings and sliced Mozzarella cheese for 14$.They are the best for quality and price in the Williamsburg area for New York style pizza in my book.
… more
… View more