Long-running pizzeria counter creating pies from homemade dough & daily made sauce. Based on 89 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2418 St Lawrence Ave, Long Beach, IN 46360
Phone: (219) 874-4268
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Britney Hanzel
* edit after having another piece later today:
… more
Wendy Neal
I always liked pizza and little giant was my favorite until last night, I ordered a 6 topping pizza and when I got it delivered about an hour later it was burnt, the crust was inedible, literally they had to know how burnt it was and still sent it out, I don’t think I’ll ever order from them anymore, for what I paid for that pizza, they should be ashamed.
… more
Madison Moore
Best pizza in the Michiana area and at a competitive price. Sauce and crust are phenomenal. Staff told us everything is made from scratch and it shows. Highly recommend.
… more
Mickey Chambers
The worst pizza it is all doughy and not even cooked all the way through. And mangers didn’t even want to fix there mistake for the doughy pizza that wasn’t cooked thumbs down for the pizza and mangers
… more
Melissa Hubbard
We are from KC MO and are traveling for business. This was the closest delivery to our hotel. I took a chance based on the reviews and we are NOT disappointed!! The pizza is DELICIOUS!! We ordered the Fiesta pizza and sausage pizza both on thin crust and we LOVED both!! The medium pizza is the size of a large at pizza hut.
… more
Jason Frazier
Great place good pizza and nice employees. My parents met Tom the previous owner at opti-fast back in 1986. Weight loss shake diet back in the 80s. Great guy funny character. He passed out his business cards to people at this dieting program while he was in it. Hilarious move! Anyways in fall of 86 our family decided to buy his pizza. It was very good! Been a fan going on nearly 35 years now!
… more
Tina Sass
Absolutely wonderful pizza. Friendly employees!
… more
Kimmy Tancil
Getting pizza on our vacations is a tradition and I just happened to find a gem. If you’d blink, you’d miss this place. Google maps will get you there just fine though. This was one of the best pie’s I’ve ever had! We ordered the large regular crust with sausage and extra cheese. IT WAS AMAZING! So much so that 3 of us ate it all! The crust was thin, but we like it that way. We’ll definitely be returning here for our pie’s!
… more
Johnny wad
I’ve been eating this pizza for at least 20 years and it has just seemed to be getting worse and worse ever since the place changed owners. Last night was the final straw. Ordered my usual Fiesta and it was just not a good experience at all. Pizza was luke warm at best and the crust was just plain soggy. It’s really a shame too because we don’t have many original pizza joints in Michigan City. Albanos here I come!!!!
… more
Mercedes McMullen
Was really disappointed. Ordered stuff crust pizza and only got a thin crust pizza with topping under cheese and sauce. I called in and they said it’s made that way. We’ll that not stuffed crust and your charged more. Need to really change that. The garlic bread was a hoagie with cheese thrown onto wasn’t tasty at all. Very disappointed.
… more
… View more