Lobster Rolls No. 1 Menu – Fort Myers, FL

Type : Restaurant

Location : Fort Myers, FL

Based on 197 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Lobster Rolls No. 1 33919

Address:
8595 College Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Phone: (239) 202-8795

Website:

Hours

Saturday 9 AM–8 PM
Sunday 9 AM–7 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
9 AM–7 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 9 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 9 AM–7 PM
Thursday 9 AM–7 PM
Friday 9 AM–8 PM

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Erin Duffy
Casual spot to grab some lobster rolls. I love the older lady that works there. She’s so personable. I got the CT roll, so it was warm with butter, just how I like it. I ended up ordering 3 for me; I made two meals out of it 🙂 I will absolutely come to this place again!

… more

Danette Bertulli
My husband and I ate here for the first time today and it was really, really good! Authentic lobster rolls, they were delicious, not over dressed or greasy, fresh and full of lobster. Everything we had was great. They are a new restaurant, expanding their services and options, soon to be adding the addition of a Danish bakery! We’re definitely be going back!

… more

Crystal Rose
Lisa/Fort Myers location was delightful. The food was amazing! We ordered a lobster bisque, a clam chowder and two Connecticut lobster rolls and drinks ($74.00)

… more

JD Wilson
Had a wonderful time with excellent customer service. The lobster roll was so delicious, the best thing on the planet.

… more

Andra
Excellent! Best lobster roll! Classic and Connecticut style. Plus, their bisque is great, too! They also have a German Bakery in the store front. All delicious! Going back soon! Spread the word. We need to keep this jewel in business!

… more

yung belle
stopped in today for an 18$ Lobster Mac n Cheese. it was a pretty small portion but had a good couple chunks of lobster. it could’ve been cheesier to me. the only downside is that i heard the employees saying “it’s in the microwave right now” and they had MICROWAVED my food to warm it up; it was hot and cold, didn’t even have the decency to mix it!!! i thought they would keep like a crock pot or something going all day? it was disappointing because the pasta was way over cooked and idk i thought they would at least pop it in an oven, crisp up some cheese/breadcrumbs on the top, something. it was good, but it’s way too expensive to be sitting in a fridge and microwaved in front of customers. i don’t see them sticking around for long, place was dead during Friday lunch rush. owners quite snarky and unprofessional in replies, surely they won’t like this one either. not a good look to paying customers giving honest feedback.

… more

Ryan Thuener
Nice and fast sit-down place with delicious lobster! Had the sampler, and all were very good. I think the simple hot and cold was the best just because the lobster was very good on its own.

… more

Corpsman 82
Over priced lobster rolls with little satisfaction. I would have to say Masons downtown has better lobster rolls hands down, and judging by the owners responses to reviews, there’s not much room for improvement. Do yourself a favor and skip this place.

… more

Donna Jo
This place is amazing!!! The lobster meat gets flown in from Maine a few times per week. The rolls are filled and the meat is so sweet!!!

… more

Cindy Martin
Delicious meal with my mom! Such a wonderful, warm place with amazing friendly staff. Definitely will repeat this neighborhood gem!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions