Counter-serve chain offering fried fish & seafood combos, plus chicken & sides. Based on 62 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $
Address:
334 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553
Phone: (845) 561-3022
Website: https://www.ljsilvers.com/
Reviews
Chrystal C
Never go late, best to not waste your money. Long John Silver’s is definitely one of my favorite places to go for fast food. However going to this location around 8-9 at night is a bad idea. We stopped here because we both were hungry and it was pushing 9 and felt it was too late to cook. We both ordered the 2 piece fish and 6 shrimp platter and a soda. The first issue I had was I received my $13.65 change in coins, being told they had no bills in the store. This I could look past if the rest of the experience was not so bad. We had to wait a good 15 to 20 minutes for our order. I thought well I don’t mind waiting for fresh food, if only that was the case. Once in the car we check the bag and find 2 of our sides missing, go inside and get them no problem. Then at home we find out that not only was the shrimp old and hard we received only 3 shrimp each, and although the fish is hot, it is very hard as well. Needless to say I don’t think I will be going to Long John’s again at least not for quite awhile. The whole experience has ruined it for me.
… more
Mary Latimer
The food is always good but they have the nicest group of young people working there. People are quick to complain, but slow to praise. They always go out of their way to be pleasant. The crew that worked on Sunday 4/15 were especially nice.
… more
Daria Schondra
Me and my grandson went the on in New Windsor. Got food for use and his 2 bothers and there mother. The food had as funny smell when I put into the car. And we ordered fish and shrimp. The shrimp had a funny flavor. Like the taste of baking soda. That might be an ingredient in the batter. But the shrimp just didn’t taste right. And that is bad, when you pay big money for food that nobody can stomach. I also noted the place was not clean. So sad.
… more
Jessica Stevens
Every time i go to long john silvers and KFC any of them basically the new Windsor one and order the famous bowls they are not hot they are barely warm. I ask them to heat it they say they cant they can give me another one. Why get another one its going to be the same lukewarm. You need to change they settings no one wants to eat lukewarm food would you? I said you have a microwave just nuke it he said its to hot for the food all he has to do put it in for less time can’t he think that far? Where do you get the employee’s from under a rock?I am done with eating there the employees are not to smart they look at you and scratch their head.Mores the pity when they have no idea what you are talking about.
… more
L S
Been here a few times. Can be quite good or fish can be excessively greasy. Last time it was terrible. Greasy, overcooked and inedible. Not like most LJS that seem to be more consistent in quality. I come back since it’s the only one in area. It’s like playing Russian Roulette in the food quality. As Forest Gump might say , LJS in New Windsor is like a box o’ chocolates. “You never know what you’re going to get.” Grade C- / D+.
… more
Renee Pastore
I haven’t had this in quite a few years, we recently moved to the area, so my husband & I are sampling all the places around, I had the 2 piece fish platter, it was sooooo good, in the late afternoon early evening they cook to order, so that’s the best time to come, it’s hot & freshly made, this store is right around the corner from our house, we will be here quite often, my husband loves the hush puppies
… more
John Pangle
Very rude . Insisting I wear a mask when the guy sitting down behind me isnt. The cook isnt , and shes got one on not covering her nose or top lip.
… more
LCD PLASMA INSTALLATION
Beyond horrible experience. Place is dirty and no one seems to care. Order was wrong but didn’t say anything because I don’t want my food spit on or dropped. Food was not cooked properly. I will not return.
… more
Carmelo Maccarrone
Well not great it was Kentucky Fried Chicken As Long John Silver I think the chicken place was better but I had fish and chip
… more
Chris Welch
Order fresh everytime no matter what looks the staff gives you. Just smile and enjoy the delicious fish and shrimp and chicken
… more
… View more