Lucy's New York Style Pizza Menu

Unassuming local chain eatery serving up thin-crust pizza, plus calzones, subs & salads. Based on 177 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Lucy's New York Style Pizza 83301

Address:
210 2nd Ave S, Twin Falls, ID 83301

Phone: (208) 933-2000

Website:

Hours

Sunday	Closed
Monday (Labor Day)	10:30 AM–9:30 PM Hours might differ
Tuesday	10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Wednesday	10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Thursday	10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Friday	10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Saturday	10:30 AM–9:30 PM

Twin Falls 1 Starters & Salads Ordering
Breadsticks Our breadsticks are baked with garlic butter and seasonings. They are served with our house made marinara.	$5.00
Cheesesticks Enhance our breadsticks with mozzarella…enough said!	$6.00
Firesticks This delicious appetizer is a hybrid of hot and mild flavor. They are basted with buffalo sauce and then topped with cheese and jalapenos. Yum!	$7.00
Fried Mutz Our delicious whole milk cheese hand breaded and fried, served with marinara!	$5.00
Wings (10) Ten tasty chicken wings doused with your choice of sauce. Choose from our signature buffalo, sweet chili, honey garlic, or BBQ sauce. Served with ranch or blue cheese.	$12.00
Boneless Wings (10) Real chicken chunks breaded and fried, with you choice of sauce!	$12.00
Meatball Our 10-ounce zesty meatball smothers with our house made marinara.	$7.00
Pickles And Olives Dill pickles spears and our marinated olives	$2.50
Half Caprese Salad Not a traditional salad by any means, including flavor. (3)Slices of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil. Lightly seasoned with salt, pepper and olive oil.	$4.50
Full Caprese Salad Not a traditional salad by any means, including flavor. (6)Slices of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil. Lightly seasoned with salt, pepper and olive oil.	$8.00
Antipasto Salad Green salad topped with cheese, tomatoes, olives and a variety of peppers, topped with pepperoni, salami, and ham.	$9.00
House Salad A small green salad with cheese, olives, pepperoni, tomatoes and pepperoncini.	$4.00
Family Salad This king size version of our house salad comes with cheese, olives, pepperoni, tomatoes and pepperoncini. Perfect if your group has an appetite for leafy greens!	$14.00
Twin Falls 4 Pizzas Ordering
Flavor Of The Month Slice Check out our website or ask any employee for this month’s special flavor.	$4.00
Roni Slice Who doesn’t love a giant slice of classic pepperoni pizza?	$4.00
Cheese Slice You cannot go wrong with the classic. Whole milk mozzarella cheese on our hand tossed thin crust pie.	$4.00
Margherita Slice This slice offers a fresh bite. Fresh sliced tomato and basil on a classic cheese pie.	$4.00
12 Build Your Own Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.	$11.00
12 Half&Half Specialty Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can’t decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $9.50!	$11.00
12 Meaty The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$18.50
12 Supreme Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$16.50
12 Margherita This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$13.50
12 Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$19.00
12 CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$14.00
12 Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$13.50
12 Veggie This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$16.00
12 BBQ Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$12.50
12 Buffalo Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$12.50
12 Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.	$15.00
12 Zim A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$16.50
12 BLT This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$16.00
12 Pizzle Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!	$12.50
15 Build Your Own Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.	$14.50
15 Half&Half Specialty Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can’t decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $13!	$14.50
15 Meaty The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$24.50
15 Supreme Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$22.50
15 Margherita This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$18.00
15 Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$25.50
15 CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$18.50
15 Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$18.00
15 Veggie This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$22.00
15 BBQ Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$17.00
15 Buffalo Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$17.00
15 Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.	$20.00
15 Zim A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$22.00
15 BLT This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$21.50
15 Pizzle Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!	$16.50
18 Build Your Own Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.	$18.00
18 Half&Half Specialty Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can’t decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $16.50!	$18.00
18 Meaty The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$30.50
18 Supreme Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$28.50
18 Margherita This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$22.50
18 Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$32.00
18 CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$23.00
18 Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$22.50
18 Veggie This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$28.00
18 BBQ Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$20.50
18 Buffalo Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$20.50
18 Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.	$25.00
18 Zim A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$28.00
18 BLT This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$27.00
18 Pizzle Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!	$20.50
GF Build Your Own Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.	$11.00
GF Half&Half Specialty Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can’t decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $11!	$11.00
GF Meaty The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$15.00
GF Supreme Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$15.00
GF Margherita This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$14.00
GF Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$16.00
GF CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$13.50
GF Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$13.00
GF Veggie This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$15.00
GF BBQ Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$12.50
GF Buffalo Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$12.50
GF Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.	$14.00
GF Zim A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$14.00
GF BLT This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$14.00
GF Pizzle Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!	$12.50
Take&Bake BYO Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.	$9.00
Take&Bake Half&Half Specialty Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can’t decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $9!	$9.00
Take&Bake Meaty The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$16.50
Take&Bake Supreme Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$16.50
Take&Bake Margherita This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$12.00
Take&Bake Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$18.00
Take&Bake CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$12.00
Take&Bake Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$12.00
Take&Bake Veggie This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$16.50
Take&Bake BBQ Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$10.50
Take&Bake Buffalo Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$10.50
Take&Bake Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.	$13.50
Take&Bake Zim A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$15.00
Take&Bake BLT This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$15.00
Take&Bake Pizzle	$11.00
Twin Falls 5 Calzones Ordering
Small Calzone – Meaty The meaty calzone comes stuffed with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$9.75
Small Calzone – Supreme Our Supreme calzone comes filled with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$8.75
Small Calzone – Margherita This refreshing calzone comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$7.25
Small Calzone – Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$10.50
Small Calzone – CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$8.00
Small Calzone – Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$7.25
Small Calzone – Veggie This calzone is a vegetarian’s dream stuffed with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$8.50
Small Calzone – BBQ Chicken A calzone with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$7.25
Small Calzone – Buffalo Chicken A calzone filled with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$7.25
Small Calzone – Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce stuffed with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms. A staff favorite!	$8.50
Small Calzone – Zim A calzone that will make anyone stand at attention. A delicious calzone stuffed with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$8.75
Small Calzone – BLT This delicious calzone boasts our creamy ranch sauce, bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$9.00
Large Calzone – Meaty The meaty calzone comes stuffed with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!	$18.00
Large Calzone – Supreme Our Supreme calzone comes filled with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.	$16.00
Large Calzone – Margherita This refreshing calzone comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!	$13.00
Large Calzone – Zestpian This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.	$19.50
Large Calzone – CCB Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.	$14.50
Large Calzone – Pacific Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!	$13.00
Large Calzone – Veggie This calzone is a vegetarian’s dream stuffed with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.	$15.50
Large Calzone – BBQ Chicken A calzone with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$13.00
Large Calzone – Buffalo Chicken A calzone filled with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.	$13.00
Large Calzone – Blaise Honey stinging ranch sauce stuffed with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms. A staff favorite!	$15.50
Large Calzone – Zim A calzone that will make anyone stand at attention. A delicious calzone stuffed with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.	$16.00
Large Calzone – BLT This delicious calzone boasts our creamy ranch sauce, bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$15.50
Twin Falls 6 Subs Ordering
Meatball Sub An instant favorite! Our 10-ounce meatball sliced and coated with marinara and melted cheese.	$10.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub A hand breaded chicken breast smothered in our house made marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.	$9.50
Pepperoni Melt Sub Our classic pepperoni and marinara covered in melted whole milk mozzarella.	$7.50
CCBLT Sub A browned bun with our fresh made chicken breast topping, bacon, romaine, tomatoes and ranch.	$9.50
Twin Falls 7 Desserts Ordering
NY Cheesecake A slice of delicious New York cheesecake. Have it plain, with caramel, or dark chocolate!	$5.00
Gluten Free Brownie A brownie for anyone’s palate. You won’t even know it’s good for you!	$4.50
Cannoli Tube-shaped shells of fried pastry dough, filled with a sweet creamy filling.	$1.25
Twin Falls 8 Xtras Ordering
2oz Marinara Made fresh daily marinara sauce.	$0.50
2oz Dressing Just needing a little more sauce, pick your palates desire.	$0.50
3 For 1 Ranch	$1.00
Pint Of Marinara Our made fresh daily marinara sauce. Take a pint home and enjoy it in any home made dish.	$6.00
Pint Of Dressing Need more sauce?! Here’s a pint you can have for now or later!	$6.00
12 Dough Ball Take home one of our fresh made 12 dough balls to create a pie in your own kitchen.	$2.00
15 Dough Ball Take home one of our fresh made 15 dough balls to create a pie in your own kitchen.	$2.00
18 Dough Ball Take home one of our fresh made 18 dough balls to create a pie in your own kitchen.	$2.00
Gluten Free Crust A delicious personal size gluten free crust.	$4.00
Pizza Packet Everything you need to make a 15 pizza right in your home. Dough, sauce, cheese, topping, and a cooking sheet! Your choice of cheese, pepperoni, or ham!	$9.00
Twin Falls 2 Beverages Ordering
2LT Pepsi	$3.00
2LT Diet Pepsi	$3.00
2LT Starry	$3.00
2LT Rootbeer	$3.00
2LT Mtn. Dew	$3.00
Twin Falls 9 Catering Ordering
Party Salad Our classic house salad, made for the masses. Green salad topped with shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, black olives, grape tomatoes, pepperoncini’s. Serves 20	$28.00
Pickles And Olives A platter of our dill pickle spears and marinated olives. Serves 15	$15.00
Gluten Free Brownie Bites Gluten- free brownie bites dusted with powdered sugar. Feeds 15	$30.00
15 Cannolis Our luxurious sweet ricotta filling in a baked pastry shell.	$18.75
Wings (45) 45 chicken wings with your choice off buffalo, BBQ, sweet chili or honey garlic sauce. Serves 15	$54.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

D R

Everyone’s else got a really good quality of pizza ,he serve my pizza well done burn I don’t want complain to him ,I just left the place .

… more

Roy Fernandez

Dry hard pizza slices.. tasted horrible.. like they’ve been sitting for awhile… made my wife sick later that night…

… more

Carol Weber

Outstanding service, pizza & meatball subs. Cool atmosphere too. Very, very close to NY style. Chewy crust, tangy sauce, stringy cheese. Meatballs are on point. Our go-to in Twin Falls.

… more

Jason McDonald

This new pizza joint was amazing. Checked out the new 2nd street Market and decided to try this pizza. So good! Might be the best pizza in Twin Falls. My girlfriend and I loved every bit of the pie and the breadsticks.

… more

Mike Reynolds

We only have a picture of the root beer because we ate the pizza too quickly. It was THAT good. The setting of Lucy’s is unique as well. It is in a food court-like area without the mall. Lucy’s was very reasonably priced for the 15 inch pizza we got there. The crust was crispy but not burnt, it also had a subtle sweet flavor. The sauce, cheese, and toppings were also exceptional.

… more

Dodgerman Games

I’ve bought 5 pizza in 3 weeks and it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had. The first time I was curious because I’ve never had New York style pizza before and ai picked up two 18” pies and brought them home. I gave my wife two slices and went back to get mine and I heard her say “Oh my gosh this is so good!l Hearing that ai couldn’t wait and sat down to eat mine and it’s a good thing I was sitting down because It was so good I had to sit down.the people here are friendly and I can’t wait to go back again and try the calzones.

… more

Kristyn Hansen

The pizza was so good. Hard to find good pizza around here, I’m so glad I found this place.

… more

Great pizza and friendly service. The 12” filled me up. Could’ve fed two. Cost about $13.

… more

Victoria Toone

Great pizza! Hot, cheesy and the crust was perfect.

… more

Forever four Funny family

I love this place!! Megan and all the staff are so sweet!! The food in delicious! You get a big bang for your buck!! My portion was too big to finish!! Megan & her team make you feel like you’re @home!! I definitely recommend this place! they must try is the Oreo calzone! I thought I died and went to heaven! So so good! Yum! This restaurant is definitely the heart of Twin Falls!

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Lucy’s New York Style Pizza Menu – Twin Falls, ID

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions