Based on 298 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
142 Fifth Ave, Village of Pelham, NY 10803
Phone: (914) 365-2561
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Lupita Alvarez Valencia
Our son turned 13 years old today and picked this place for his birthday dinner and we are all happy he did, it was great. Little did we know this gem was only 10 mins away from our home. Everything from the calamari, tomahawk steak, pasta, drinks and dessert was top notch. Our waiter was very welcoming as well, he made sure all of our food was out in a timely manner. Will definitely recommend this place to all my family and friends.
… more
Wembley Lighting
I was there with my wife when Tony and John was the owner every time I went I got deferent price while they were there and I was not happy I stopped going there however since Bacci took over I love it the price is decent and service is great very human and very welcoming. The best service and steak I love going there now. This is great place to be in Pelham if you want to eat.
… more
Ace Acevedo
Nice quaint place. Had ribeye, medium rare… It was perfectly cooked. Extremely limited choice of premium scotch… But the service and ambiance more than makeup for it… Would recommend it anytime…
… more
Randal Paster
I didn’t experience any problem with the parking. Although, I recognize that it can be problematic. The food was great. The service was phenomenal. There were four waitresses working together beautifully as a team. Very attentive, and intuitive. The only complaint that I have, and forgive me I don’t enjoy complaining, but the acoustics in the place make it much louder than it should be. It wasn’t crowded, one table of 6, another table of 3, and our table of 2. There were a few conversations going on, of course, but the decibel level was way too high. It was more than I could handle.
… more
Randal Paster
Parking was not a problem at the time of my arrival. Parking can be problematic for sure. The food was quite good. The service was phenomenal. My only complaint is the acoustics of the place. It wasn’t crowded. One table of 6, another of 3, our table of 2. Several conversations being had, of course. But the decibel level was very high ( deafening), I couldn’t handle it well.
… more
Desiree Hill (Desican215)
Came all the way from Philadelphia and went here yesterday to celebrate my little sister’s 21st birthday. It was such a delightful experience and the food was delicious! If you like seafood and pasta, I recommend the linguine and clam pasta. Shout out to our waiter Julian! He was the best!
… more
Matthieu Vatinelle
I absolutely love coming here for dinner. Every single dinner is divine and the wine selection is better than anywhere I’ve been. You’ll always leave this restaurant with a smile on your face. Excellent service and ambiance. Would recommend to anyone.
… more
Glitch Roblox
Not the waiters fault , very understaffed. NOTE WHEN WE WERE THERE IT WAS US AND ONLY 2 other tables a party of 2 and 4 plus us 3 in the entire restaurant!!!My mussels were ice cold with warm sauce poured over them out food took over a hr if not longer to come out and all we ordered was a medium rare steak a salad and 2 sides.. TERRIBLE FATHERS DAY EXPERIENCE. I MUST SAY AGAIN THE WAITER WAS VERY EMBARRASSED AND WAS NOT AT FAULT AT ALL.
… more
Jessica McGovern
The food here was awesome! The service was spectacular! Best steak house in New York! Have friends and family visit all of the time and this the first restaurant I take them too! Highly recommend.
… more
Allison Silvers
I wish I could give 6 stars. This place has the most delicious food and terrific service. I’ve struggled to find a decent restaurant in Westchester, and I’m so pleased to have found Macelleria. Menu variety is perfect, the portions are good, and everything is melt-in-your-mouth tasty! Highly recommend!!
… more
… View more