Malarkey’s Menu – Hilton, NY

Type : Hamburger restaurant

Location : Hilton, NY

Based on 32 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Malarkey’s 14468

Address:
144 South Ave, Hilton, NY 14468

Phone: (585) 366-7017

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 4–10 PM
Wednesday 12–7 PM
Thursday 4–10 PM
Friday 12–11 PM
Saturday 10 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–5 PM
Monday 4–10 PM

Menu

Snacks and Bites
Mozzarella sticks
Six mozzarella sticks served with warm marinara		 $8.00
Chicken Tenders
Deep fried chicken tenders served with choice of sauce		 $10.00
Pizza Logs
Four deep fried logs served with warm marinara		 $8.00
Sides
French fries $5.00
Home Fries $5.00
Onion rings $5.00
Mac Salad $5.00
Coleslaw $5.00
BBQ Baked Beans $5.00
Macaroni and Cheese $5.00
“Talkin Trash” plates
Cheese burger plate
2 cheeseburgers over any 2 sides topped with meat hot sauce and onions		 $14.00
Red hot plate
2 Zweigle’s red hots over any 2 sides topped with meat hot sauce and onions		 $14.00
Pulled pork plate
Our slow smoked pulled pork over any 2 sides		 $14.00
Chicken Tender plate
Chicken tenders over any 2 sides with choice of sauce. Meat hot sauce extra		 $14.00
Spuds
Loaded fries
French fries topped with cheese, bacon, meat hot sauce and onions		 $12.00
Thruway fries
French fries topped with Buffalo sauce, meat hot sauce and blue cheese		 $12.00
Loaded chicken fries
French fries topped with deep fried chicken tenders, cheese and bacon		 $14.00
Hand pressed burgers
American classic
Burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and onions		 $8.00
Roc burger
American cheese, hot sauce and onions		 $8.00
Yeehaw! Burger
Topped with Swiss cheese, bacon, BBQ sauce and fried onion rings		 $9.00
Malarkey burger
Topped with American cheese, grilled ham, chopped lettuce and Malarkey sauce		 $9.00
Bacon cheeseburger
Topped with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion		 $9.00
Naughty melt
Texas toast grilled cheese with a burger Texas toast grilled cheese with a burger topped with American cheese firecracker mayo and fried onion rings on Texas toast		 $12.00
Texas grilled cheese
Grilled cheese
Grilled cheese sandwich on Texas toast		 $5.00
Grilled cheese with pork
Grilled cheese sandwich with our slow cooked pulled pork		 $10.00
Grilled cheese with ham or bacon $7.00
Pork Sammy’s
BBQ pulled pork sandwich
Our slow cooked pulled pork on a grilled roll		 $8.00
Drunkin’ Pig
Pulled pork topped with slaw and fried onion rings		 $9.00
Pig Sty
Pulled pork topped with grilled ham, homemade relish and Malarkey sauce on Texas toast		 $11.00
Chicken Sammy’s
Marinated Chicken Sammy
Grilled chicken topped with lettuce tomato and onions		 $8.00
Cluck Norris
Grilled chicken topped with grilled ham, Swiss cheese, honey mustard, lettuce and tomato		 $9.00
Knuckle Sammy
Fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce and topped with bacon and blue cheese		 $9.00
Country Blues
Fried chicken topped with bacon and pickles and drizzled with blue cheese and country sweet		 $10.00
Other
BLT
Bacon lettuce and tomato on Texas toast		 $8.00
Zweigle’s red hot $5.00
Homemade Mac and cheese
Mac and cheese $9.00
Mac and cheese with pork $11.00
Mac and cheese with bacon $10.00
Buff Mac
Mac and cheese topped with fried chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo		 $12.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ryan Staples
I ordered a Cheeseburger Garbage Plate via GrubHub and WOW this is one of the best plates I’ve ever had around here. Perfect Mac Salad, the Meat Hot has just enough kick, the burgers are thick, and the home fries are crispy. I’m so excited that I dont have to drive 25 minutes to DogTown anymore! Great job!

… more

Jeff P
Great owners, Very personal and professional. Wonderful atmosphere and great food. Place for great garbage place. Come all do not seconed guess. Family owned and operated support local buisness

… more

Joseph Zelazny
After my pregnant wife requested a garbage plate I went to get one at a local place but they ran out of mac salad somehow (things happen). however, it lead me to Malarkeys, I called in 2 garbage plate orders and within 10 minutes it was ready and the employee was very easy going and pleasent to speak to. Food was hot and delicious, one of the best garbage plates I’ve had in awhile. Ignore the one review that shows one star, I have a feeling that it was probably cold because they took too long to eat it, took to long to get it, or it was a salad because mine was good and hot and fresh!

… more

Erin Baker
Everything here is delicious!! The plates are amazing, the breakfast sandwiches are fantastic (especially the Malarkey Doodle Doo!), and the meat hot sauce is the best I have ever had in my life!!

… more

Michael Valvano
Hands down the best garbage plate I’ve had in a very long time. The Mac salad is delicious, the meat hot is actually hot and full of flavor, and the price was more than reasonable. Thanks Again!

… more

Ryan Penna
Best plate in I’ve found so far, fantastic, fresh and huge! You will not be disappointed I promise!

… more

Liz Bausch
Delicious food, reasonable prices and awesome owners! Love Malarkeys!

… more

Don Wenzel
Have only been in a few times but I got to say the plate was outstanding. It must have weighed 3 pounds.

… more

Chris C
Malarkey’s guys are great . I dropped my cheese burger plate on accident . The guys running kitchen made me a new plate one right away . Great work guys .

… more

Brian Dobson
Just tried here for the first time and really good food. Super fresh, seasoned well great portions. I got a plate, daughter a burger, and my son got chicken fingers. Everyone loved it. Price is right too!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch