Based on 50 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
Address:
105 S Taylor St, Marengo, IL 60152
Reviews
Kris Adams
GREAT pizza . Friendly atmosphere great price glad a new pizza joint open in marengo.
… more
Dr Lee
This is a one and done type of place. The food just doesn’t taste good you can tell from right when you open up the box that the quality is poor. With stone bakers right around the corner this place will surely be out of business shortly. I ordered sausage on half of my pizza and there was a total of one piece of sausage.unreal. Save yourself the adventure of trying a new pizza joint and go where you always go trust me .
… more
Rocky B
Anyone who gives this a 1 star and says it’s not good clearly doesn’t know what good or fresh food is. Particularly because they live in the middle of nowhere and don’t understand good food. This place is an absolute diamond in the ruff, best pizza this area and the surrounding area will ever see. This is a real pizza with not frozen ingredients. So what the desert is frozen, you base your entire review on the desert? It’s a pizza place….you want desert go to one of the 57 ice cream places over here. Malito’s please keep up the GREAT work your city loves you !
… more
jef x
This is probably my favorite local pizza joint. But be aware that its delivery/takeout only, and they have a limited menu. If I had one complaint, it would be a lack of cheese on the pies. Everything else is sooo good. The crust is perfect, the sauce is delicious, the toppings are quality, the family operated small location is cute and charming, the cheese is almost perfect…..It’s just not enough. I think the Thin crust pies need double what come standard, and the Deep Dish needs 2-3 times what they put on it (Deep Dish is supposed to be ALL ABOUT CHEESE), Don’t get me wrong, I will continue to get my pizza from here, I just have to order everything with more cheese. Maybe if we all order “Extra Cheese” every time, they will get the hint. wink wink
… more
Steve Tolvstad
Pizza is average. I’d give it a 5 out of 10. Family owned. Unfortunately they treat there delivery driver’s poor. 4 fired in my brief time delivering for them. They tend to make fun of there customers. Giving them Nicknames and even taking pic’s off Facebook and using them for amusement. As for the restaurant in general, they keep it pretty clean.
… more
Scott Downs
Ive eaten a few thousand pizzas in my time. A lot of Chicago type I e Beggars, Palermo’s and Nick and Vito’s. This pizza stands right up to them.
… more
alan king
Not bad, cheese is really good, the mushrooms were fresh and tasty. The crust was thicker than I like it and it was light on the sausage. I’m sitting on a fence with the sauce. Good service and price, that’s a big plus. I just might try it again.
… more
Beata Chmielewska
Went there for the first time tonight. I do Keto and they have cauliflower crust only on small size pizzas. It’s so good, wish they have bigger size on crust pizza (hint hint lol). Keep it up great work, coming back for sure in upcoming weeks. Thanks for not making me cook tonight and still staying Keto.
… more
Laura Rose
They have the freshest ingredients I’ve ever had on a pizza, every time we order. About once every 2 weeks. It’s the best pizza out of the 4 pizza restaurants and takeout and delivery by far in Marengo. They’re always very friendly and the price is right. Also their Chocolate cake is incredible and unbelievably gluten free. We won’t ever order from anyone else in Marengo. The only bumber is they’re not open on Mondays!
… more
Nicky Gliosci
I’ve Ordered multiple times and the staff is always nice and welcoming, on top of that the pizza is by far the best pizza I’ve had in years, if you’re not into pizza there meatball sub is to die for. I highly recommend Malito’s.
… more
… View more