Based on 166 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
200 W Summit Ave, Wales, WI 53183
Phone: (262) 968-2255
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joelious Ames
Date night. Came in around 9pm on a Friday. This was the best find ever. The garlic bread. Just wow. Our server, Makenzie (probably misspelled) was amazing. I can’t describe how much we enjoyed ourselves. Food was spectacular. Service was perfect. I couldn’t imagine a better experience. Thank you very much!
… more
Patti Stolpa
Recommend reservation on a Saturday night.
… more
Emily Keller
I normally don’t write many reviews, but felt the need to after my experience. I had high hopes for this restaurant for takeout on a busy weeknight. First of all I was charged the wrong amount at checkout and I needed to wait 10-15 minutes for them to fix it as my food was getting cold and kids were getting hungry. Upon getting home I was cutting up my son’s meatball and it was like a petrified piece of coal. I almost broke my knife cutting through it. I decided I couldn’t serve it to him. The two orders of lasagna were dry and burnt on most of the edges of the servings. And cold. The garlic bread was soaked in butter. It was really soggy and didn’t taste like garlic bread. I’m normally not a picky eater or person but this was some of the poorest quality takeout food I have ever received.
… more
Christine Lundwall
Garlic Bread-WOW-So Good! We had cheese and sausage 1/2 onions. Was made perfectly! The crust (just the way we like) thin and Crunchy! The BEST pizza in town….Be prepared to pay.. their prices went up..but it was worth it!!!!!
… more
Denny
We used to go to Mama Mia’s regularly but haven’t been for a few years. We went tonight and ordered garlic bread and pizza. Garlic bread was good. Pizza lacked flavor. We had the Classic.
… more
Scott Steinhorst
Went there to eat with a few co-workers and hadn’t been there in a number of years. The appetizers and everyone’s food was nothing short of AMAZING!! We even had to take pictures of the garlic bread, to die for! The only thing better than the food was the awesome service from Sydney, extremely pleasant and super fast. Great place to go!!!
… more
Teddy Budny
This was during the week about 5:30 pm. Staff was very friendly. We ordered egg plant & one piece of garlic bread for an appetizer. The egg plant was small pieces of something and priced out at $9.00; horrible.
… more
Bear walking into the shade. (YoSoyMolimo)
Food was great, service was terrible. Our host was not very nice at putting on a fake nice face and it just made her seem bitchy. Our waiter was friendly, but waiting wasn’t the job for him. He had no visible sense of humor, never checked on the table or offered refills. Didn’t clear any used dishes. And didn’t leave with a closer, which could have been as simple as “have a good evening” when leaving the receipt. We got the EBA (Everything but anchovies) pizza and it was outstanding! The garlic bread is my vote at states best! Hopefully, the staff at our next visit will be a little more on board to host dinner!
… more
Brian Borden
First terrible experience of many visits. Normally the food I’d awsome. Last night we started off with cold garlic bread . To move onto a terrible pizza with little to no cheese, flavorless sauce and very little sausage ( we ordered double sausage). We will try again because normally this place is awsome. Normally worth the 85 mile trip….
… more
C J
Excellent food and drinks. They have great daily specials. Some of our favorite dishes are Lasagna (hubby’s fav) yummy Mac and cheese, the garlic bread is “out of the world”, pizza is excellent also. If you are wanting a good Italian meal, this is the place!!!
… more
… View more