Pizza, calzones & other basic Italian fare served in a long-running joint with an old-school vibe. Based on 233 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1529 W 38th St, Erie, PA 16508
Phone: (814) 790-5868
Website: http://www.mamamiaserie.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
| Sunday | 3–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J Sun
8/24/23 – Excellent food. Friendly employees. Visiting Erie, friends of mine made Mama Mia’s one of the must visits due to a variable unique to this Resteraunt; Fried Banana Peppers. In all my travels be it home or on the road I hadn’t ever had this previously. Well worth it. Great idea, tasty facilitation of idea. Asked the woman who assisted me at the counter and she happily chatted and gave me some background. Mac and Cheese bites were tasty, and got a 14″ pizza extra cheese feta and roasted red peppers, was also extremely happy with the taste a quality. Great place here in Erie. Glad I made a point to stop here while visiting. Highly recommended!
… more
sus gus
Recently just had the best Buffalo chicken pizza of Erie from this place. The spice was above average but did not need a drink to calm it down. The fire roasted chicken was a fantastic touch, not too much ranch either. All perfect proportions and delicious. Will definitely get again!
… more
Valerie Herock
I ordered a small pizza with extra cheese, mushroom and half pepperoni…I didn’t like the pizza at all. There was hardly any cheese on the pizza which surprised me being that I did order extra cheese. The crust was so so. I definitely wouldn’t recommend the pizza. However I did order parmesan garlic wings…they were fantastic!! Perfect crispness and juicy, just the right amount of seasoning and a side of ranch. I would definitely recommend these. So tasty. The price was a little high for me though. All in all I probably wouldn’t order from here again.
… more
Ben Cavalier
In town for a travel hockey game. We searched for nearby pizza places and landed on this place.. We got Wings, Italian subs and cheese pizza.. Everything was awesome and the prices are hard to beat. Highly recommended
… more
Leah Griffith
BEST PIZZA EVER. Tried it a few weeks ago when we were on a little weekend trip to Erie. It was so freaking good that we packed our two year old and three month old into the car today and drove all the way from Cleveland just for their pizza. I don’t know if it’s the sauce, the crust, the perfect amount of cheese or all three but damn, it’s good pizza. Worth a trip from anywhere if you ask our family. Thanks, Mama Mia’s. You’re our favorite!
… more
Harry Meyner
This is my first time getting a pizza and mamma Mia’s and I have to say it was the best pizza I have had in 20 years
… more
J___ S___
Pizza is quite good but they don’t put any sauce or toppings on the outer 2 inches of crust. Felt ripped off a little.
… more
Shelly Walker-Graham
Best Pizza! Service is really amazing. Everyone there is ALWAYS in a great mood
… more
Pat Wenzel
Love their pizza crust. We get their pizza several times a month. Reasonable prices. Very good food
… more
Darlene Bigos
Stopped here before going back to Buffalo,NY on way from shopping and wanted to have something that was not a chain restaurant. Food was delicious and tasted fresh out of Italian kitchen. Tammy one of the owners, I believe made us feel like we were long time customers, and was only our first visit. Stromboli was made fresh to order…and loved having the choice of three different sizes of anti pasta.
… more
… View more