Based on 105 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
18 E Main St, Evansville, WI 53536
Phone: (608) 882-6666
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eppi Wiltse
Great coffee, and don’t even get me started on the lemon blossoms, scones, sticky buns, chocolate croissants…I have to stop – I’m making myself drool.
… more
Sarah Batinich
my husband and I orders from this place more. we love the food and the service. They are all very nice.This place treats their customers so nice. if ever get the wrong topping on your pizza they go out of their way to make it right. Very clean place to go on Evensville for pizza , or breakfast ,dessert are very well! Any thing you would order from this place is good all around. nice hang out spot. i would recommend this place others
… more
Evelyn Collins
Ordered take out on a busy Friday night of a school function. We had a large order. We picked it up and when we got home, it was everything we hoped for. Whoever was baking pizza and cheese bread did an excellent job. The crust was perfectly done. The person that waited on me at the counter was professional and polite and efficient. He got me checked out in a hurry so I could be on my way. Mama Rita’s is a favorite place of ours for take out and eating in. Thanks for a good experience.
… more
Jim Verbick
Their pizza is great, but their donuts are amazing. Last year, another local restaurant was supposed to cater a birthday party for us, but they just stopped responding to contact after giving us a quote. Mama Rita’s stepped up and provided great food at a very reasonable price. Highly recommend.
… more
Rebecca M
This is a well-rounded stop: delicious coffee, unbeatable bakery goods, and outrageously good pizza. In addition to wonderful edibles, the staff is always friendly. I can’t recommend this place enough.
… more
Anne Johnson
I stopped in for coffee and a treat with my daughter and had a great time. The Hawaiian Hazelnut coffee was delicious and we loved our Apple Praline muffin. The service was great and the atmosphere charming. We’ll definitely be back!
… more
Jerimiah Lathrop
My girlfriend lives in Evansville and she had great things to say about Mama Rita’s. Unfortunately I can’t say that I had a great experience myself.
… more
LS LS
I ordered just a pizza with pepperoni and extra sausage about 3 weeks ago or so. It was average and I think they forgot my extra sausage. So tonight I ordered a pizza with pepperoni and triple sausage as the guy on the phone called it. I think they thought I said triple cheese because there’s enough cheese to start a small cheese store with on the pizza and 25 pieces of sausage and 17 pepperoni slices. I also ordered the garlic cheese bread that reminded me of the Orv’s Good n Garlic Cheese pizza you get in the frozen foods section of your local grocery store but the thin crust not the rising crust. Let’s just say that the 1☆ was 1 too much!! I’m very disappointed with my food and will never order pizza from Mama Ritas again.
… more
Elliot Faber
I’ll give the pizza a 7/10 decent but not the greatest. The service gets 8/10 cuz it took 35 minutes to get 1 pizza. Overall I wouldve gave 4 stars but the bakery is just an empty cooler and that was half the reason we went
… more
John Forst
Finally tried it after a few years of existence and it wasn’t worth the wait. The Pizza was very bland and had no flavor. I wanted nothing more for it than to be good, if not great. It tasted like it had pizza sauce from a can that wasn’t given any personal loving.
… more
… View more