Mama Mia’s Too is a family-owned BYOB restaurant located in Oak Ridge, NJ. We are open for lunch and dinner and serve a full Italian menu featuring all types of Pizza, Hot and Cold Sandwiches, Antipasto, Soup, Pasta, Chicken, Veal, and Seafood Dishes. We Provide Catering For All Occasions. Ask about our dinner and pizza specials!
Based on 89 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3043 NJ-23, Oak Ridge, NJ 07438
Phone: (862) 322-2586
Website: https://mammamiapizzatoo.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christine M
Eh. Don’t really like it. Pizza sauce is too sweet. Delivery was quick, but pizza was luke warm at best. We are 10 minutes away. Tastes and looks like reheated pizza, not fresh. Not sure. Possibly because it was cold.
… more
Chris Hanke
We just tried this place for the first time and it is excellent!! I am very picky with my pizza and this was definitely 5 star food and service!! From the door we were greeted and treated with great attention. Kids got a personal pepperoni pizza, my wife and Son split fried calamari, then my wife and I had a Pepperoni, mushrooms and cheddar cheese pizza!! I kept saying to my wife that this was like bar pizza and it was perfect!!! Absolutely will be eating here again and again.❤️❤️
… more
Mike Lopez
My friends and I went to Mamma Mia’s Too last year and the food was amazing. So when we were was back in that area (since I don’t live around there) I wanted some amazing food again. OMG! Once again we weren’t disappointed. Amazing food and while we were waiting we got to play cornhole. Pretty sweet. They did a big renovation from the last time I was there and it t looks sweet. You got to try this place!
… more
Christine Vander Ploeg
Food was delicious, service was amazing and they were very accommodating. The arugula salad was excellent with nice presentation. My husband and I both had dinner dishes, chicken piccata and veal francese which were prepared to perfection and made to meet our dietary needs. A great addition to our hometown, we will be back.
… more
Pamela Gonoud
So happy to have found our new go to pizzeria!! It is beyond delicious making it very dangerous that it is on my husband’s way home from work!! So happy they deliver to us on the mountain in Sparta and delivery always comes earlier than estimated time!!! Absolutely delicious!
… more
Madeline Barr
We’ve lived in west Milford for 6 years and are just discovering this gem of a pizza place! It’s hard to please both me and my husband but Mamma Mia’s got it done! So many gluten free pizza options, and regular pizza is fantastic as well! The best part is their employees are polite and courteous, and the deliveries are on time. What more could you want in a pizza place? This is our new go-to!!!!
… more
Jimmy Burns
Love the food here, we’ve been ordering last few weeks and food is always amazing. Service is great and staff is always so helpful. I never know what to get and they always recommend the dishes that end up tasting amazing. The Sicilian pies and zeppolis are delishhh. Great food, price and employees. What more can you ask for. My weight gain thanks you! We just ordered today again too. IM FULL CANT MOVE !!!
… more
John Slootmaker
Just ordered from there and have to say this was the worst pizza and chicken parm sandwich I have ever had ! Such a disappointment ! We waited over 2 hours for our food to be delivered and when it got here it tasted like we ate rubber with sauce that’s even if there was sauce on it! The garlic knots were so oily and not even cooked it was like biting into raw dough! Tried calling and no one was available to talk! I Don’t recommend this place to anyone!
… more
Lisa Comer
This is one of the better pizzerias in our area. We started ordering from here when they first opened this location, knowing that Mama Mia’s (the original store, different location) food was fantastic. They have never disappointed! My absolute favorite dish is their baked ravioli!!!! I never have left overs! Love, love, love this place!!!!
… more
Jenice Camarena
This place is the same old nasty Pizza Station with a new banner. Placed an order at 5:27, received it at 7:02 in its soggy glory. The food was obviously cold, and soggy. The meatball was pink and had a freaking hair under it. The fries were sad and wet. The garlic bread was a mistake. The mozzarella sticks were so disgusting from being ‘cooked’ hours prior. For a $50 order, I am absolutely beyond disappointed. I stopped going to Pizza Station after complaining about the same things: soggy old food with hairs in it, and here I am again. This was a waste of $50 and I’m freaking ANGRY.
… more
… View more