Mamma Santina has been in the hands of the same owners since 1987. From the moment they first opened their doors, until now, they have striven to provide their customers with the highest quality Italian cuisine and gourmet specialty pizzas. The smoky taste from the wood-fired oven, homemade fresh mozzarella, and imported San Marzzano tomatoes make you feel like you’re dining in a trattoria right in the hills of Sicily. Mamma Santina is actually the owners’ “mamma”. It was named after her to continue the legacy of her traditional style of cooking.
Based on 365 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
201 Orinoco Dr, Brightwaters, NY 11718
Phone: (631) 665-7880
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday |
10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday |
10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday |
10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday |
10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Melanie Prince
Absolutely consistent & outstanding food & service. Long Island is over saturated with bars & restaurants but the welcoming staff at Mamma Santina’s makes you want to come back, especially the bartenders Jen & Alexa. The bar & dining room is completely renovated which really enhances the guest experience. Plus they have their own parking lot which makes it such an accessible & convenient spot in the heart of Brightwaters.
… more
Hashtag ONLYKRIS
Great place for an authentic Italian, family style cuisine. Such good people. My mother is 100% Sicilian, and very hard to impress… she was amazed gave everything a HARD five stars…. do yourself, and your loved ones, a favor…. eat at Mama Santinas!!
… more
Mashiro S
We went there for dinner, ordered salami pizza, cheese pizza and Caesar salad. The pizza here is definitely a delight. It was baked very well, where the dough slightly caramelized and there’s a bit of crust. Cheese tastes nice and the tomato sauce beneath is done the correct way. Salad is above average.
… more
Jonathan Klomp
Okay so I should have photographed my food…. Instead I ate it quickly. I very much liked the pasta fagioli and my wife had drunken Sabrina…. Nice place…. Not an ordinary pizzeria
… more
Anna Ronan
If I could give more then 5 stars I would! We catered for my husband’s birthday yesterday and everything was incredible from the food to the service and the price was totally reasonable, we got so much food! Our food was delivered on time, hot and ready to eat. They included an extra pint of vodka sauce with the penne alla vodka and a pint of lemons alongside the baked clams. Everything was so neatly packed with care and made SO FRESH. Thank you for a delicious meal. We will continue to order from mamma santina for the best Italian food!
… more
John Feminella
Good food plentiful, I had calamari over Pasta. Would like to have seen some tentacles in there, but it was all tubes. Wife had the muscles which she raved about, Prices were fair I would definitely recommend.
… more
Louise Tedesco
What a hidden treasure in the Village of Brightwaters. Will be back next week. Laura G. Is a great singer and added a nice touch to our dining experience
… more
Edward Lupo
Stay clear of bartender Tim who works on Sunday night.
… more
Vincent Hoosack
Had my daughter’s birthday party here for pizza and soda. They were very helpful and welcoming for our party. The lay out of the tables was perfect and they had the pizza out in a timely fashion. The servers were well attentive and had every done with a smile. I am very pleased and would strongly suggest this to anyone thinking about having a child’s party. Well done. Thanks again.
… more
Rocco Palomba
This Restaurant is newly renovated, and it was tastefully done. The food was good and reasonably priced. I would personally not dine there again however because I had to listen to loud poorly chosen music throughout my visit. I found It very offensive during my dining experience.
… more
… View more
