Based on 167 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
71 W Main St, Allegany, NY 14706
Phone: (716) 373-2754
Website: http://mangiapizzaallegany.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Hillary Moninger
We stopped there by chance– so glad we did! I ordered a slice of pickle pizza- i know… But it was delicious. We also got the Gouda mac/ cheese bites- also good. The sauce was good too but too spicy for me.
… more
Robert GEsayz
Great place for huge slices of thin crust pizza. It’s greasy but the grease is not nasty if that makes sense. If you don’t like thin crust this is not for you but I love it. Sausage is not recommended but cheese and pepperoni is excellent. Cost about 2.50 a slice.
… more
CM Potter
Sad I didn’t think to snap a shot of the slice with dill pickle. Paper thin crust which I LOVE! Very cool music playing through a great sound system.
… more
Dan G
This is the 3rd time I’ve gotten pizza slices at Mangia’s in the last month, and I have to say that they are consistently AMAZING! Just look at the pic I’ve attached: I included part of my hand for you to be able to have some perspective on just how HUGE their slices are! Forget the other local pizza joints and make Mangia your go-to place for pizza!
… more
Deetra Meyer
This was a little out of our way, but it was so worth it! Absolutely the best pizza ever. Can’t wait to return to NY, will go out of my way to grab me a good pie!
… more
Megan Smith
Quick spot to get a slice of pizza as you go through town. Thin crust and nicely cooked- I like mine a bit more crispy/welldone.
… more
Shane Anderson
Wings were phenomenal — crispy, juicy, large. Sauce was decent, had a large variety. Pizza was very good, small tip for future orders with Pineapple on Pizza, might want to grill up the pineapples a little beforehand so they’re not squishy.
… more
Christine Gabler
I am usually super impressed and love Mangia’s. Today I am very sadded by the cost and quality I received. I ordered the fried dough bites for 2 elementary classes working about a block away- after a $ 7.00 delivery fee that was scribbled out on the receipt but still added to the total but then another line was added by hand for tip- getting the treat cost me $12.00- twice the price of an order of the dough. An afternoon order of pizza was delivered to the school for an afterschool group (after they had agreed to take off the delivery fee and I could pay the tip in cash), the group did not eat the 23 1/2 cookies that arrives because many of them were burned. Just disappointed- 3/$2.75– $22.00 for 2 dozen cookies (2 1/2 ” across). See picture. Wow– do I feel cheated! Trying to do something extra for my students- lesson learned. Be cautious– Not what it used to be!!
… more
R Williams
We love Mangia pizza. But this week was the first time we tried their wings. We decided on the breaded wings. Wow! They hit it out of the park. These wings were amazing. First of all, their price per wing was cheaper than most of their competition for both Buffalo wings and breaded wings. I think they might hand bread them themselves – not sure but the breading was delicious & different from all the other breaded wings around (def not just frozen Wingdings). The sauce was a little different than we’re used to but on point. The flavor was unique and amazing. But the pièce de ré·sis·tance was the size. These bad boys were monsters. Biggest wings I’ve had anywhere local in a long long time. They were not quite as crispy as we like but that is to be expected on a to-go order. They were the bomb!! We also had a regular pizza and their spicy Italian pizza. Both were delicious & cooked to perfection as always.
… more
Natalie Roberts
Taste not bad. But quality..not. Bought a XL 18 in pie. We got double cheese,double pep. 30 bucks. Pizza is paper thin,had to remake,only to wait 15 mins for it to be sturdy enough to eat. But even with the double double,how much can you put on it and be able to eat it. Taste is OK,but not worth 30 bucks
… more
… View more