Family-run Italian standby for classic thin-crust pies, calzones & more in a modest setting. Based on 236 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
489 Valley St, Maplewood, NJ 07040
Phone: (973) 378-8588
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Okang McBride
We order for a little work luncheon before holidays and everything was solid from the pizza, salad to the garlic knots. You won’t be disappointed so definitely give this place a try.
… more
KevLar Da Don
Tried, Maplewood Pizzeria, for the first time in ages (10+ Years ). I got the Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Parm, & Margherita Slices. Also with a side of Marinara (For the crust #TML). The Buffalo Slice was very good. Would give it a solid 6/10. The Chicken Parm Slice was decent. Would give it a 4-5/10. Their Margherita slice on the other hand was very disappointing. Would give it maybe a 2-3/10. The Marinara Sauce on the side was also extremely disappointing. Not much flavor to it tbh. All in all, even though this particular instance wasn’t the best, they have a really nice staff and some decent slices. There was enough flavor to make an unclouded, but unfulfilled, judgement. Will have to try their other menu items to give an official rating, but would def recommend, Maplewood Pizzeria, for anyone looking for moderately priced and decent tasting pizza in the MAPSO area!
… more
Daniel S Abrahamian
When it comes down to quality, there’s no room to play favorites. Good location, but better ingredients make better pies.
… more
1N_Only Gigi
We live in Elizabeth… and definitely don’t mind taking the drive just to get their pizza!!!! Amazing!!!!!
… more
Edward Osoliniec
Great local pizzeria. Always the same great quality and service.
… more
JP Howlett
Great pizza and they make strombolis the right way — so delicious. I pick up my orders that I place online from the site that Google Maps links to and it’s always ready quickly and I can get in and out really fast — employees are on point. All the staff is also friendly. They are my go-to pizza place.
… more
Gloria
Overpriced and inconsistent with the quality and quantity of their food! I literally just ordered mozzarella sticks and wings (lunch special) I received 3 wings and 3 mozzarella sticks for $8 plus tax . They use to give 5 wings and 5 mozzarella sticks or whatever side you ordered with it for around $5 plus tax. My order would’ve been fine but not for $8!!!
… more
Peter Bednarz
Great pizza. Tried the caramelized onion, chicken, bacon, and fresh mozzarella. One word, delicious! Will be coming back…
… more
•Lights on•ツ
It’s a great place the people who work there are very nice and friendly as a child from the high school it can get chaotic in the afternoon. As in a lot of children tend to hangout there and fight and oftentimes the staff has to get involved.
… more
gloenci
terrible customer service, overpriced for little bit of food and treat school students terribly, the young guy with the glasses threw my order at me when i had simply asked for it after waiting a long time and gave unprofessional service. This food isn’t that good for them to be treating their customers like the way they do. I say go to Sab’s down the street from it!
… more
… View more