Based on 41 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
86701 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 735-4247
Hours
| Saturday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–2 PM |
Reviews
Thitima Tubsan
I never had bagel anywhere tasty like this place. I’m in love with sesame bagel with onion cream cheese and put salmon on it was the best!!!! Good price and good service also I recommend.
… more
Gunther Prussing
Once you eat here, you’d be absolutely insane to go anywhere else for bagels in all of south Florida. Or breakfast in general in all of the keys. I’m so happy they opened up a place closer north. If you’ve never had bagels from NY or Jersey before, now is your chance. There’s nothing like it. From their own cream cheese flavors, they’re perfectly baked bagels, and their quality breakfast options, it’s top notch.
… more
Brandon Hernandez
Great tasting bagel, perfect amount of cream cheese. All at a great price! Sorry for the picture of a mostly eaten bagel, it was so good I forgot to take a picture first. Definitely recommended for breakfast in Islemorada.
… more
R D
The bagels were good. Not the greatest and not what you would expect if you are looking for a bagel from Brooklyn, but they are good. Prices are reasonable as well and the menu is good.
… more
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
The wait is finally over, marathon bagel Co. is now in Islamorada. Amazing New York, New Jersey style bagels with a great selection. Open until 2 o’clock, closed on Mondays. Very friendly staff and great atmosphere. In the pelican plaza next to Puerto Vallarta! Quick service great place to stop if you’re in a hurry or if you’d like to relax, they have plenty of dining space.
… more
Micky Christian
We were leaving the Keys after a awesome week long vacation and heading to the airport in Miami. We needed real food.
… more
Gary Gross
I had an everything Bagel with whitefish salad and it was as good as anywhere…highly recommend. Mike and his staff were super friendly. Portions were generous for the price. Highly recommend!!!
… more
marsha Teal
Quick stop on our way to an activity. The service was quick. We each got a bagel with eggs and bacon. Mom said hers was a little salty but I did not think that.
… more
Maggy Pollicino
NY, NJ, and Long Islanders: this is the place to go if you’re tired of Dunkin’s bagels. Gives me a LI bagel store feel, different cream cheese options piled high, a fridge with juices, lemonade, etc and a basic coffee selection with flavored creamers. Prices are very reasonable considering what their rent must be right off U.S 1. $2.79 for a bagel with cream cheese, around $5 for an egg sandwich. Only place in the Keys I’ve found decent bagels, I usually make my own every few weeks, but I’ll be happy to support this business when I don’t feel like baking!
… more
Kathy Denworth, Fl Keys Realtor
Best Bagels and cream cheese in the Keys. Their Southwest breakfast bagel is NOT what you would expect. It is NOT peppers ham & onions mixed in egg. It IS a slice of ham with and egg on it, topped with sauted peppers and onions. YUMMY.
… more
… View more