Based on 676 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
45 George Dye Rd, Hamilton Square, NJ 08690
Phone: (609) 586-5770
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Keeran Vigar
Visited all the way from the UK to try the famous pizza and it did not disappoint! So tasty and a great price! A little sad that i didn’t get to meet Sally but i still had awesome service. I’m visiting jersey for 2 weeks so i will be coming back again very soon!
… more
Yeetius Yeetington
Drove here from Long Island yesterday and it was absolutely worth the drive. Pizza was fantastic, incredible flavor on the cheese and sauce while maintaining a light, crunchy crust that you have to try to believe. On top of the great food we met the man himself Sally Slices; he was very kind, welcoming, humble and an all around great guy to chat with as we waited for a few pies to come out the oven. This place is worth the hype and next time we’re in Jersey we’ll definitely be back!!
… more
Jonathan wilke
Me and my fiancé were on a trip from Wisconsin to Newark NJ and as soon as we landed the first thing we did was get on a train and go to Marcello’s!! Of course we were going there to try the original Corleone and see the legend Sally Slices! Let me tell first impressions Sal had the most amazing attitude to see us! He treaded us like royalty to say the least! We both had a piece of Corleone pizza and an order of garlic bread knots! Let me tell you this pizza was not even close to any other pizza I have had in my life! The way the bottom of the crust is so crispy but yet the middle is warm and soft and the top was perfectly cooked. The bread knots were like nothing I have ever had there was actual chopped up garlic on them. What really makes this place special is the atmosphere I felt like I walked in and have known Sal my whole life. The icing on the cake was making a video with the legend Sally slices himself! Keep up the awesome work Sal and everyone who makes Marcello’s so special will definitely go back when I get the chance again!! To anybody looking for the best pizza ever and the most amazing atmosphere and people look no further then Marcello’s Pizza-Grill!!!! Thanks for the best pizza and most amazing experience Sal much love brother keep up the amazing work!!!
… more
Amy Xu
Came here to see Sally with my friend! They serve their unique “Corleone” style pizza — which is like a hybrid New York-Chicago style pizza — and it is incredibly delicious! I got chicken bacon ranch, my friend got pepperoni. I particularly liked the crunchy cheese bits on the crust. Though we didn’t meet our favorite Tiktok celebrity, we were more than happy with our pizzas
… more
Nicholas Santangelo
Great place. Little outlet where you’d never expect this quality of pizza! Highly recommended! Had the Corleone pizza. Great square pizza! The tomato sauce gives a more rosse kinda vibe. Not the run of the mill. Excited to see they have sfincione on the menu! Will need to check that out next time!
… more
Sandro Scapin
The best pizza ever. Sal was such a sweetheart. Very welcoming and so kind. Made my kids soooo happy by taking a picture with them. We will definetly be back again. Thank you Sal 🙂
… more
Andrew James
Flew all the way from Mississippi to try this place out.
… more
Brian Mikus
Great pizza. Sally Slices is super friendly and definitely cares about his products. He loves his customers and enjoys spending time talking to us.
… more
Harley Daigle
This place is Great! Home of the Corleone, Marcello’s Pizza-Grill. If you Travel or are in New Jersey this place is a must. Home to SallySlices, the TikTok sensation and Son of Marcello. I got lucky enough to try fresh Pizza made by SallySlices. Meeting Sal was the cherry on the excitement Sundae. The staff are all professional, kind, and work together as any great team should. Not just Corleone Pizza in a wide variety of Toppings, but a Cannoli and Tiramisu that is next Level. The BEST!! I recommend you go.
… more
Jason Persaud
Definitely worth the hype!
… more
… View more