Margarita's Cafe Hicksville Menu

Margarita’s Cafe offers fine Mexican and Mexican inspired cuisine as well as exotic drinks. We feature amazing margaritas and offer live Mariachi bands as well.
We offer in house catering for all sorts of functions with packages for every budget. Our Hicksville location was the third restaurant we opened.

Based on 598 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Margarita's Cafe Hicksville 11801

Address:
392 Woodbury Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801

Phone: (516) 931-1694

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11:30 AM–10 PM
Wednesday	11:30 AM–10 PM
Thursday	11:30 AM–10 PM
Friday	11:30 AM–11 PM
Saturday	11:30 AM–11 PM
Sunday	11:30 AM–10 PM
Monday	11:30 AM–10 PM

Appetizers*
Aguacate Relleno Avocado stuffed with diced shrimp, a dash of lemon juice, and topped with red onion, radish, cilantro, and a pinch of paprika.	$15.95
Alitas De Pollo Choice of buffalo or bbq wings. Served with celery sticks and blue cheese (seven ea).	$15.95
Ceviche De Camarones Shrimp, celery, cucumbers, onions, avocado mixed with cocktail sauce, and cilantro. Served with plantain chips.	$18.20
Chicken Mexican Quesadillas	$20.50
Empanadas Homemade empanadas filled with meat and potatoes, topped with shrimp and chicken in Willy’s old special sauce.	$18.20
Fried Calamari Deep fried calamari served with Willy’s homemade Saratoga and Tampiqueña sauce.	$19.35
Guacamole Al Molcajete Freshly made a la vista. Avocados, jalapenos, tomatoes, onions, lime and cilantro. Served with warm tortilla chips and salsa sauce.	$17.05
Jalapeno Poppers Deep fried, stuffed with Cheddar cheese. Served with guacamole and sour cream.	$15.95
La Familia Buffalo chicken wings, nachos, chicken taquitos, jalapeño poppers, chicken roll, chorizo, and quesado. Served with guacamole, jalapeños, sour cream with Tampiqueña sauce.	$34.15
Mexican Quesadilla Flour tortilla stuffed with shredded mozzarella cheese. served with veracruzana sauce guacamole and sour cream.	$19.35
Nachos Supreme Freshly made tortilla chips topped with refried beans, melted cheese, veracruzana sauce, jalapeños, guacamole and sour cream.	$15.95
Queso Fundido Melted Mexican cheese, chorizo, salsa roja, baked in skillet topped with cilantro and onions. Served with side a flour tortilla.	$17.05
Sol Ranchero Nachos and quesadillas topped with melted Mexican cheese, jalapeños, sour cream, guacamole, and Tampiqueña sauce.	$18.20
Steak Mexican Quesadillas	$21.65
Taquito De Pollo Crispy rolled tortilla stuffed with chicken, topped with queso fresco, crema, and guacamole sauce with tampiquena.	$15.95
Tostone Rellenos	$19.35
Shrimp Mexican Quesadilla	$21.65
Salads and Soups*
Margarita Salad Mixed salad with Romaine, iceberg, cucumber, tomato, and grilled zucchini. Served in a crunchy taco shell bowl, and topped with queso fresco and balsamic vinaigrette.	$12.50
Mexican Avocado Salad Served with mixed salad, Romaine, iceberg, red cabbage, red onions, tomatoes, and avocado. Served with margarita dressing.	$15.95
Sopa Azteca Blended chicken soup with Pasilla Chile, and tomato. Topped with Oaxaca cheese, avocado, sour cream and tortilla chips.	$10.25
Taco Salad Mixed salad with Romaine, iceberg, cucumber, and tomato with choice of ground beef or shredded chicken topped with Mozzarella, black beans, and balsamic vinaigrette.	$17.05
Salmon Salad Pan seared salmon over mixed salad, Romaine, iceberg, tomatoes, and cucumber with lemon garlic sauce.	$22.75
Sopa Negra Black bean soup.	$9.10
Sopa De Pollo Chicken soup with peppers, onions, potatoes, carrots, and celery.	$9.10
Side Orders*
Espin Al Ajo	$6.80
Guacamole Side of guacamole.	$6.80
Maiz Blanco Sautéed peruvian corn.	$6.80
Melted Cheese Melted nacho cheese.	$6.80
Platanos Fritos Con Crema Fried plantains with crema.	$6.80
Rajas De Jalapenos	$6.80
Shredded Mozzarella	$3.40
Sour Cream	$2.25
Tamal De Elote Sweet fresh corn tamale with sour cream.	$6.80
Tortilla Chips (Extra)	$4.55
Tostones Fried plantain disks.	$6.80
French Fries	$6.80
Platos De La Casa Entree*
Tacos De La Casa Crispy corn tortilla shell with choice of shredded chicken or ground beef Mexican style, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and Tampiqueña sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.	$21.65
Tacos Al Carbon Soft corn tortilla with diced grilled chicken breast sautéed with red sauce, onions, and a dash of cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Tacos De Pescado Soft corn tortilla shell with pan seared tilapia, topped with pico de gallo, queso fresco, and cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.	$25.05
Tacos De Puerco Soft corn tortilla shell with marinated pork loin, sautéed with adobo, garlic, onion, and cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Tacos Mexicanos Soft corn tortilla shell with choice of C.A.B. grilled skirt steak or shrimp sautéed with butter, onions, a dash of cilantro, and red sauce. Topped with pico de gallo and queso fresco. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Enchiladas Entree*
Enchiladas De Chorizo Soft rolled corn tortilla stuffed with Mexican chorizo. Topped with guajillo sauce, and melted Oaxaca cheese. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Enchiladas De Mole Poblano Soft rolled corn tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken. Topped with mole sauce and melted cheese. Served with rice and refried beans	$22.75
Enchiladas Rojas Mixtas 3 soft rolled corn tortillas, one with steak, second with chicken, third with cheese, and topped with red sauce and Mexican cheese. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Enchiladas Rojas W/ Steak Just steak.	$25.05
Enchiladas Suizas Soft rolled corn tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken or shrimp. Topped with green tomatillo sauce, melted Mexican cheese, and sour cream. Garnished with onion and cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.	$22.75
Platos Tipicos Entree*
El Rey Burrito Soft tortilla stuffed with chicken, chorizo, beans, sautéed mushrooms, and topped with Tampiqueña sauce and Mexican cheese. Served with rice and refried beans.	$25.05
Burrito Mojado Soft flour tortilla with Willy’s style C.A.B. skirt steak sautéed in salsa rojo, stuffed refried beans, Mexican cheese, and lettuce. Topped with green tomatillo sauce, crema, and guacamole sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.	$27.35
Cheese Quesadilla Flour tortillas with cheese. served with refried beans and rice. meal includes one soda.	$23.90
Chimichangas Crispy rolled flour tortilla, choice of shredded beef or shredded chicken topped with Tampiqueña sauce, sour cream, and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Fajita Frita Flour tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken, Mozzarella cheese, sautéed onions, and peppers. Topped with chilango sauce and queso fresco. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Flautas Crispy rolled corn tortilla stuffed with Mexican style chicken, pepperson, onions, and carrots and topped with Tampiqueña sauce, sour cream, and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Homemade Tamales Homemade tamales wrapped in corn husks, stuffed in corn meal dough with choice of chicken or beef. Baked and topped with a non-spicy homemade chipotle sauce and melted cheese. Served with rice and beans.	$23.90
Pollo De La Casa / Chicken*
Alambre De Pollo Two open flame grilled chicken skewers with onions and peppers. Served over rice and avocado salad.	$25.05
Arroz Con Pollo Strips of lean chicken breast sautéed with garlic butter with refried beans.	$25.05
Mole Poblano A traditional dish of Mexico with sautéed diced chicken topped with a complex assortment of sauces and over 25 ingredients. Served with rice and refried beans.	$25.05
Pechuga Adobada Adobo marinated grilled chicken breast with guajillo sauce and pico de gallo. Served with rice and refried beans.	$25.05
Pollo Aguacate Grilled chicken breast with melted Mexican cheese topped with a touch of Tampiqueña sauce and garnished with avocado. Served with rice and refried beans.	$25.05
Pollo Jalisco Chicken breast sautéed with artichoke hearts, jalapeños, capers and white wine lemon butter sauce. Served with black beans.	$25.05
Pollo Margaritas Chicken on the bone, marinated in our oldest secret recipe. Fried and baked with white wine, lemon, garlic, and cilantro. Served with rice and black beans.	$26.20
Vegetarian*
Chile Poblano Pan fried Poblano pepper in our secret batter and egg mix, filled with wild mushrooms, baby spinach, and Oaxaca cheese topped with green tomatillo sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Quesadillas De Calabacita Flour tortilla stuffed with grilled yellow and green squash melted cheese. Topped with salsa ranchera, sour cream, and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.	$23.90
Tijuana Wrap Flour tortilla wrap with mixed vegetables, beans, sour cream, and guacamole. Served with refried beans.	$23.90
Carnes Tipicas / Steaks*
BBQ Shrimp And Chicken Shrimp and chicken. Served with rice and beans.	$31.90
Cerdo En Adobo Picante Grilled pork chop marinated in chipotle adobo topped with sautéed red and green peppers. Served with rice and black beans.	$29.60
Bistec Ala Brasa C.A.B. grilled New York strip steak with roasted seasonal vegetables, moro rice, and mariquitas.	$30.75
Bistec Con Camarones C.A.B. tender shell steak marinated in a Mexican style broth, served with shrimp a la Tampiqueña sauce. Served with rice and black beans.	$35.30
Carne Ranchera C.A.B. grilled skirt steak strips, topped with onions, peppers, jalapeños, red sauce and adobo Mexicano. Served with rice and black beans.	$31.90
Costilla De Cordero Al Chipotle Grilled baby rack of lamb chops rubbed with a chipotle and garlic adobo, topped with guajillo sauce. Served with rice and black beans.	$30.75
Mexican Faldita C.A.B. grilled skirt steak strips. Served with black beans, topped with queso fresco, rice and avocado.	$30.75
Parilla Mexicana Serves for two. Baby back ribs, BBQ chicken, steak, shrimp, and grilled chorizo, salad, black beans, and rice.	$58.10
Ropa Vieja Mexicana Braised and shredded flank steak, topped with classic salsa Havana criollo. Served with sweet plantains, rice and black beans.	$31.90
Tampiquenas CAB grilled shell steak and cheese enchilada topped with tampiquena sauce. Served with rice, beans, and avocado.	$30.75
Margaritas Skillet	$37.60
Mar Bueno / Sea Food*
Camarones Al Chipotle Tequila flamed shrimp in chipotle sauce, in a fried taco bowl. Served with rice and refried beans.	$28.45
Camarones Empanizado Batter-coated, deep-fried shrimp, fried to golden brown. Served with rice and avocado salad.	$28.45
Camarones En Salsa Verde Jumbo shrimp in an emulsion of fine herbs, garlic, white wine, and infused green tomatillo sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.	$28.45
Jambalaya Shrimp, chicken, chorizo and crawfish meat sautéed with green peppers and onions over Cajun style Mexican rice in Tampiqueña sauce. Served with avocado salad.	$30.75
Mar Y Tierra Lobster tail, tender grilled CAB shell steak, shrimp, guajillo sauce, and queso blanco. Served with black beans and Mexican rice.	$45.55
Mariscada De La Casa Veracruzana Lobster tail, shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels in a green tomatillo and garlic broth. Served with rice and black beans.	$44.45
Mixiote De Salmon Grilled salmon fillet marinated in guajillo sauce with manchamanteles and sour cream. Served with avocado salad and Mexican rice.	$31.90
Paella En Cazuela Lobster tail, shrimp, chorizo, scallops, clam, and mussels sautéed in a white wine garlic sauce and tossed with saffron rice.	$44.45
Quesadilla De Langosta Flour tortilla filled with lobster meat, Mexican cheese, adobo sauce, guacamole, sour cream, and Tampiqueña sauce. Served with refried beans and rice.	$34.15
Pescado Blanco Tilapia sautéed in garlic, olive oil, white wine, and Veracruzana sauce. Served with rice and seasonal vegetables.	$27.35
Fajitas Entree*
Chicken Fajitas Sizzling marinated chicken strips on a bed of sautéed onions and green peppers. Served with rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole, pico de gallo, and lettuce with choice of flour or corn tortilla.	$27.35
Fajita Combo Combination of shrimp, chicken, and C.A.B. marinated skirt steak strips on a bed of sautéed onions and peppers. Served with rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole, pico de gallo, and lettuce with choice of flour or corn tortilla.	$34.15
Salmon Fajita Sizzling salmon filet on a bed of onions and peppers garnished with wedges of lemon.	$27.35
Shrimp Fajita Sizzling marinated shrimp on a bed of sauteed onions and green peppers.	$29.60
Steak Fajita Marinated steak strips, onions, and green peppers. Serves 15 to 20 people.	$29.60
Vegetarian Fajita Served with guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream, rice, refried beans, lettuce, and flour tortillas.	$25.05
Kids Menu*
Kid Chicken Fingers	$15.95
Kid Cheese Quesadilla	$15.95
Kid Beef Burrito	$15.95
Kid Arroz Con Pollo Strips of lean chicken breast sautéed with garlic butter with refried beans.	$15.95
Dessert*
Churros Churros stuffed with caramel and banana ice cream.	$10.25
Despacito Chimichanga Crispy rolled flour tortilla stuffed with a cheesecake filling and banana flavor.	$10.25
Flan Honey glazed homemade custard.	$10.25
Fried Ice Cream Made from a breaded scoop of ice cream that is quickly deep-fried.	$10.25
Ice Cream	$6.80
Sopapilla Mexican Pastry with honey and cinnamon on top.	$11.35
Tres Leches A vanilla sponge cake, soaked in milk and topped with whipped cream.	$10.25
Chocolate Cake Chocolate cake layered.	$10.25
Catering – Party Platter Sides*
Rice	$39.90
Refried Beans	$39.90
Fried Plantains	$45.60
Green Salad Cucumbers , tomatoes , red cabbage , balsamic vinaigrette.	$45.60
Catering – Off Premise Party Platters*
Party Platters Empanadas Beef, potato empanadas with shrimp, chicken, and Willy’s special sauce.	$106.75
Party Platters Nachos Corn tortillas chips, refried beans, melted cheese, and salsa.	$88.95
Party Platters Quesadillas Flour tortilla melted cheese, sour cream, and guacamole.	$106.75
Party Platters Alitas De Pollo Buffalo or BBQ, blue cheese, carrots, and celery sticks.	$88.95
Party Platters Mexican Fried Calamari Crispy fried calamari marinara and saratoga sauce.	$100.80
Party Platters Enchiladas Corn tortillas, stuffed with cheese, and salsa roja.	$106.75
Party Platters Flauta Crispy corn tortilla, with chicken, salsa, sour cream, and guacamole.	$106.75
Party Platters Chimichanga Crispy flour tortilla, beef or chicken, salsa, sour cream, and guacamole.	$106.75
Party Platters Burritos Roll flour tortilla and seasoned beef.	$106.75
Party Platters Arroz Con Pollo Chicken breast, garlic, butter, wine toss with rice.	$106.75
Party Platters Paella Saffron rice, shrimp, mussels, clams, scallops, chicken, and chorizo.	$154.15
Party Platters Mexican Faldita Grilled skirt steak and avocado.	$106.75
Party Platters Chicken Fajitas Grilled chicken, peppers and onions, pico de gallo, sour cream guacamole, flour tortillas.	$100.80
Party Platters Steak Fajitas Grilled skirt steak peppers and onions, pico de gallo, sour cream, guacamole, flour tortillas.	$177.85
CERVEZAS/BEER
Corona	$9.10
Tecate	$9.10
Negra Modelo	$9.10
Dos Equis Amber	$9.10
Corona Light	$9.10
Pacifico	$9.10
Modelo Especial	$9.10
Dos Equis Lager	$9.10
Heineken	$9.10
Heineken Light	$9.10
Budweiser	$9.10
Budweiser Light	$9.10
Amstel Light	$9.10
Coors Light	$9.10
Michelob Ultra	$9.10
Victorias	$9.10
CLASSIC FAVORITES
Daiquiris raspberry, strawberry, peach, mango, coconut	$13.65
Pina Colada crema de coco. pineapple juice with fine rum.	$13.65
Red Sangria	$13.65
White Sangria	$13.65
COCKTAILS/ MARGARITAS BY THE GLASS
Margarita De La Casa Tequila, triple sec and sour mix	$13.65
Margarita Special Patron, Grand Marnier, sour mix, splash of O.J.	$15.95
Margarita Maya Avion Blanco. Cointreau, pomegranate, orange juice.	$15.95
Cancun Margarita Don Julio, Grand Gala, freshly squeezed lime juices.	$15.95
Apple Margarita Sauza, sour apple, triple sec, sour mix.	$15.95
Mar Azul 3G Blue agave tequila, Patron orange liquor, blue, sour mix.	$15.95
Margarita Decorazon Corazon, patron citronge, sour mix.	$15.95
PITCHERS
1?2 PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA	$22.75
1?2 PITCHER MARGARITA DE FRUTA	$23.90
1?2 PITCHER SPECIALTY MARGARITA	$29.60
1?2 PITCHER DAIQUIRI	$23.90
1?2 PITCHER RED SANGRIA	$23.90
1?2 PITCHER WHITE SANGRIA	$23.40
1?2 PITCHER MOJITO	$36.45
FULL PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA	$35.30
FULL PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA \| #1 FULL PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA	$35.30
FULL PITCHER MARGARITA DE FRUTA	$36.45
FULL PITCHER DAIQUIRI	$36.45
FULL PITCHER RED SANGRIA	$36.45
FULL PITCHER WHITE SANGRIA	$36.45
FULL PITCHER MOJITO	$54.70

… View more

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: carbonaraapp.com opentable.com

Reviews

dory Stutman

No reservations just walk right in and 1st come 1st served.

… more

Max Cohn

Some of the food was pretty good and other items were mediocre. If you are to get something I recommend getting the quesadillas and not any of the salads. The salads are very bland. The place is relatively expensive but the service is quick.

… more

Trey Hand

I must be spoiled being from NC, but this was the worst mexican food I’ve ever had while traveling. Ordered the Chimichanga because it’s usually a safe bet. This was 3 deep fried egg roll type things with bland shredded beef inside and a scoop of avocado and lettuce on top with some bland rice and beans on the side. Maybe the other food is better, but I’ll never be back to see. Taco Bell is better.

… more

umra hai

Worst customer service, staff was very disrespectful . One of my friends had a hair in his steak fajitas and despite telling them 5 TIMES that i dont eat pork , i was still served paella with chorizo. Never coming back!

… more

Sue Ann Marie

Such a fun place with good food and music. Everyone was friendly and food and chips are tasty. Drinks are pricey but made well.

… more

Stephen DiGirolamo

The food was very tasty but, the steak fajitas did not have much steak, 5 pieces to be exact and they were small strips. It was mostly onions and peppers. Was not worth the cost of the meal. Very disappointed.

… more

H S

Very delicious food good serving and soothing ambience. Enjoyed family day out

… more

Brian Cooper

Excellent brunch. Good food helpful staff. Fun menu. I loved the steak and eggs. Perfectly cooked and very flavorful. Huevos rancheros also good. One of us had a birthday so we also enjoyed auto refilling mamosas! And decent coffee as well.

… more

Yeisy Cruz Heredia

Super overpriced for really bland food. The service was pretty decent and the place was nice/clean. But Chipotle or Moe’s is tastier than this for half the price of a meal.

… more

Brian Libert

This place is expensive and somehow the food has gotten worse. They were accommodating to my complaint but I cannot recommend this location. The churros had literally like 4 pieces. Look at the picture. Would you be happy if you received any of that?

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Margarita’s Cafe Hicksville Menu – Hicksville, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions