Veteran Mexican hideout behind an old church serves mole, margaritas & occasional tequila tastings. Based on 533 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
75 W Main St, Webster, NY 14580
Phone: (585) 872-1237
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 12–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Robin Fang
I liked the small and cozy atmosphere. The staff greeted us right away and we didn’t have to wait long to sit. The rice was quite bland but nothing that hot sauce couldn’t fix. Overall the food was okay and good!
… more
olivia fisher
I always have a great experience here! The seasonal lavender margarita was absolutely DIVINE! Very light and not overly perfume-y like I’ve had at other places.
… more
Amanda Ligor
Very nice people running and super cute spot inside . Maybe I’m spoiled after living in SoCal for 25 years, but it was ok. On the other hand this is upstate New York, so relatively speaking it was good compared to other Mexican places around here.
… more
Donald Ross
This has become our favorite Mexican restaurant. I rated the service as a three, but only due to them not having sufficient help. Unfortunately, this seems to be epidemic in every town now.
… more
Lisa Killingsworth
First time at Maria’s and it’s a neat/interesting spot, located at the back of a repurposed church. The restaurant itself is at the basement level, and has a nice atmosphere with lots of plants and decor. The menu is basic offering mainly burritos, mole, fajitas, enchiladas, tacos, etc. We enjoyed the house margaritas, though they were severed room temperature with no ice. We ordered the Mexican Flag enchiladas and enjoyed the mole sauce. Also ordered the spicy green enchiladas, however I found them to not have any spice and found them under seasoned. I think this is a great place for people who want more muted flavor.
… more
Elizabeth Goad
Maria’s is by far the best Mexican restaurant in Webster/Rochester! The food is fresh and delicious. The margaritas are authentic, no sour mix here. They are always busy and don’t think they accept reservations. But it is worth the 15-20 min. wait!
… more
Helica
The food was delicious! But the menu was a bit scarce. The delicious options we got we specials of the day so they might not always have them… The service was great but the atmosphere was a little awkward with no music playing like other restaurants. The chips and salsa were homemade and amazing. Would recommend the nachos but the burrito was mid. Please add a chimichanga to the menu and I’d be pleased the pricing was good, lower than other, less delicious restaurants. Overall would recommend
… more
Sherri Tyler
Maria’s serves up particularly good margaritas –we’ll return for that reason alone! We also enjoyed their pork enchiladas with tomatillo sauce, rice, and beans. The chips served with salsa seemed stale, greasy, and hard, although the salsa was clearly fresh and tasty. Lines are long, but move fairly quickly. The space where customers wait for tables is small, tight, crowded, and chilly when the weather is cold, though waiting at the bar is a popular option. When a restaurant is as busy as Maria’s, you know they’re doing a lot of things well. It just seemed, at least on our Saturday evening visit, they were too busy to extend even a bit of friendliness. None of the employees were rude — they were just all brisk business and no warmth. But those margaritas . . . I suppose that’s all the warmth anyone needs!
… more
Justin Rogers-Cooper
Tucked away on the first floor of a church-turned-market is Maria’s, which we happened upon on our journey around Rochester. It was worth the search and discovery!
… more
Sarah Trine
Wonderful food, wonderful service, happy we chose Maria’s for my partners birthday, best discovery! Good prices, delicious margaritas! Definitely worth checking out! Best salsa ever! Park in the back!!!
… more
… View more