Unassuming Italian & Mexican outfit with booth seating providing pizza, pasta & burritos. Based on 576 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through
Address:
850 Butternut Dr, Holland, MI 49424
Phone: (616) 399-2570
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Marc Bakker
We ordered takeout. We have been going for years and love the food. This is my one and only complaint and just hoping maybe to change this one item. The taco salad – it had always been fabulous. My order was drowned in dressing – like a soup. I was starving, so I had a few bites, but can’t finish, as every part of the salad is so soggy. Disappointed this time around.
… more
michelle rinehart
food was just ok, not our usual experience! waitress was polite and efficient. manager was abrasive. may go back!?!
… more
Michael Grunst
Got take out for a family birthday party on Saturday around 5 was told hour wait for order which was reasonable. Pulled up to the order pick up window at 6, was asked to pay and pull up to the parking to wait for food. Server came out with no food to inform half the order got missed by the kitchen and apologized. Was told another half hour wait for rest of order. Server said they would throw in some free breadsticks to make up for the extra half hour we needed to wait for the rest of the order. Seemed reasonable and did not want to argue with staff. When we got order home everything was cold. Pizza had barely any toppings, salad 5 small chunks of chicken, taco salad missing chips, subs were soggy. Really bummed out. Been going here for 20+yrs. I guess the new owners don’t have what it takes. Sad to see Mario’s slip like this. This is hopefully not the new normal. Will be hard to give a second chance or recommend.
… more
Lauren Urias
Came in for pizza and bread sticks and was not disappointed! Bread sticks were hot and fresh and had plenty of butter and tasted great. The pizza was some of the best pizza I’ve had in the area! We will definitely be back.
… more
Peter Schwemlein
Thank You Mario’s! Everything was Absolutely Wonderful and Everyone working there was so Incredibly Kind! We were visiting Holland, Michigan from Indiana for my daughter’s softball tournament. I’m so glad that we ate at Mario’s! I especially would like to mention how they were welcoming, patient, and understanding with my son who has autism. We are so Grateful! Thanks again Mario’s! May God Continue to Abundantly Bless Your Beautiful Restaurant and Hard-Working Saff Always!
… more
Brian B.
Mario’s pizza is awesome with our family. It’s a bit more expensive than the pizza chains , but of course you aren’t getting that pizza chain kinda pizza it’s much more than that! Mario’s regular cheese on their pizza is close to the extra cheese that comes from the chain pizza places.
… more
Melissa Burke
Had Mario’s for take out tonight. We ordered 2 of the 15” pizzas, cheesy bread and a few house salads. The Italian dressing they use is seriously amazing! So good. The pizza was great and cooked just right. The cheesy bread is a must have everytime I go now! They’re even good for left overs. I threw them in the air fryer the next day and they were still amazing! I’ve dined in a few times too and the atmosphere is always nice and accommodating! The Wet Burrito is also a MUST try!
… more
Scott Petty
I got two pizzas for take out on 3-31-2023 and they were delicious. I have been going there for over 30 years and my pizzas on this day were in my top five of all of the years that I have been going there. Even with the recent change in ownership, it is just as good as it has always been. I wish the new owners and employees the best and I will keep coming back!
… more
Ann Sombun
Good portion of food. The spaghetti dinner was still hot after eating it for awhile.
… more
Chuck Rinehart
The best pizza and burritos around period. Update for May 25th I was told its under new owners and well the pizza is not the same. The waitress asked how it was well to be honest its very thin and lacks the cheese they were known for. Plus I mentioned lack of sauce which it seemed void of it and they were questioned it. Pulled the cheese up to see no sauce with tip it was a $40.00 pizza. Pretty sure won’t be going back which makes me sad I loved that place.
… more
… View more